preview

Derrick Amato

Better Essays

An ignorant thing to say is “forget the old and focus on the new.” Civilization has set forth the belief that when something is old and non-civilized, then it has no use. Nowadays, human beings are looking for modern and industrialized ways to teach themselves or get information into the brain without focusing on the brain itself. It is true that the human brain has greatly evolved to the point where human beings can produce all kinds of machines, but at the same time, they still rely on the primitive brain to make basic decisions like eating or sleeping. The primitive brain is at the lowest part of the brain, just above the spinal cord, and its functions is to regulate vital body functions such respiration and it also sends sensory information …show more content…

While visiting his hometown of Sioux Falls, South Dakota in the Colorado, Amato received a head injury while he was playing football on the edge of the pool. After being rushed to the hospital, the local doctors diagnosed him with a severe concussion. Four days later, Amato released that he was able to play piano very fluently although he had never played before, his fingers seemed to find the keys by instinct and could ripple across them. He would play the piano for about six hours every day at his friend’s place. While searching on the internet to know what was happening to him, he came across Dr. Bruce Miller, who directs the University of California San Francisco (UCSF) Memory and Aging center in San Francisco. Dr. Miller said that Amato’s brain received a hit on the primitive brain and the left hemisphere. He made a hypothesis that, the part of the brain associated with creativity had probably been inhibiting the piano skills a long time ago, and so this skills emerged because for the first time, the primitive brain which received a hit during the accident, could not keep the areas associated with creativity in check. This could probably be the same case with Stephen, probably the drugs he was taking had an effect or an impulse on his primitive brain and so the areas of brain associated with smell was not kept in check by the primitive brain, and so Stephen’s heightened sense of smell …show more content…

Sacks uses is appeal to emotion. Dr. Sacks suggests that the primitive brain can accomplish fantastic things when it is used to its highest capacity using appeal to emotion. Dr. Sacks talks about the emotion of loss and he says that when Stephen’s senses returned to normal and the condition stopped, Stephen felt that he had lost something big. Stephen says that “It’s a tremendous loss. I see now what we give up in being civilized and human. We need the other—the primitive—as well...That smell-world, that world of redolence. So vivid, so real! It was like a visit to another world, a world of pure perception, rich, alive, self-sufficient, and full. If only I could go back sometimes and be a dog again” (157-158) Dr. Sacks wants the readers to feel that it is so amazing and extraordinary to use the primitive brain, that when you that ability, it almost feel like you lost a big part of you and so he wants the readers to feel sad about Stephen’s loss. Therefore by appealing to the emotion of loss, Dr. Sacks is trying to tell the readers that losing the ability to use the primitive brain is like a something in you is

Get Access