preview

Daubert V. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals Case Summary

Satisfactory Essays

James Shannon CRJS 450-001 September 22, 2014 The case of Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals which took place back in 1993 was a case where two children were born with birth defects and blamed the Merrell Dow Pharmaceutical Company saying its drug Bendectin caused the birth defects. The case played a major role in what was permitted in court as expert testimony. Merrell Dow had its own experts and research to say that its product never showed evidence of causing birth defects. But to challenge this, the parents had their own experts to say otherwise that in animal trials the drug did in fact cause birth defects. One of the things that helped the judges to determine their ruling was the Federal Rules of Evidence; this basically lays out what the scope of an expert …show more content…

The fry rule was used to help determine whether or not the test on animals would be allowed to suffice in luau of not evidence being known of birth defects in humans on Bendectin. The Fry rule is still admissible in court but if it conflicts with the federal rules it is nullified. The two justices that dissented on the case were Justices Rehnquist and Stevens. The next question what is the difference between law, fact and discretion is that the fact is what happened, the two children were born with birth defects and both mothers took Bendectin. Law is what actually a law is, the experts brought in by the families weren’t by law recognized as experts and it is judicial discretion that allows for the courts to decide which is which. Another few term our personal knowledge which what the person testifying actually knows. Hearsay what they believe to be true from some source such as someone told them or opinion which is what they believe to be true based on their prior knowledge of the subject at hand. A big issue in this case was expert testimony which is testimony given by someone believed to be an expert in their field of study or practice that

Get Access