preview

Critical Analysis Of Lewis And Clark

Decent Essays

Anna Koeneke Reading Response #1
Wide open spaces, uninhabited for miles; breathtaking scenery, unchanged for centuries. Explorers charting this great unknown; exploring this frontier known simply as the West. This common narrative of the West can be seen in movies, television, and artwork from around the globe. However, many parts of this narrative can be far from reality. West’s A Narrative History of the West, Miller’s Agents of Empire, The Lewis and Clark expedition, and Aron’s The Afterlives of Lewis and Clark all provide a counter-narrative to the traditional narrative of the “untouched” West and highlight the importance media has on the public’s interpretation of the West.
Before examining the similarities of the readings, …show more content…

Although, each reading has a different argument, all of them provide a counter-narrative to the traditional narrative of the West. West explores the false idea that the West was empty and uninhabited, and how in reality, “it holds the nation’s oldest continuously inhabited sites” (West, p.71). That the West is not a new invention, but rather it has been a “place or rather places, in the fullest human sense of the term for quite a while. It has had its own stories to tell since at least five thousand years before the earliest cities of Mesopotamia.” (West, p.71). This argument challenges the popular narrative of the West being free for the taking, as many Native American’s have lived and cultivated this land for centuries. West also challenges the narrative of Native Americans living “changeless lives” in the West (West, p. 72). West describes dynamic changes including “rivalries and collective squabbles, alliances, victories and calamitous losses, adaptations, and shifting relations among spirits and men” (West, p. 72).
West’s use of footnotes helps validate some of his claims. Especially, how various groups perceived the West. For example, when discussing the Native American perspective, West provides several books to back up his claims

Get Access