Macbeth Production Comparison Paper
A man is known by the company he keeps. This was especially true around the time that one of William Shakespeare's most well-known tragedies takes place. In medieval-age Scotland, men like Macbeth may certainly have their own ambitions, but the people that they encounter most definitely can bring about some influence on who they are or who they want to become. The differences in Macbeth's relationships with Duncan, Banquo, and Lady Macbeth illustrate how Macbeth is portrayed as vulnerable and heartfelt in the 1978 film whereas he is portrayed as aggressive and more assertive in the 2010 film.
One reason for why Macbeth is portrayed differently in both movies is because of his relationship with Duncan. Because
…show more content…
Although she may not have bipolar disorder, it most definitely comes across as though if she does, There are evidently two very different and distinct personalities that she possesses according to the original text. Whenever she and her husband are together in a group of people, she is calm, confident, and reassuring. But when she and Macbeth are alone together, the reader is exposed to a side of Lady Macbeth that is a lot more, afraid, bossy, and vulnerable. There are multiple scenes in both movies that show this, such as when Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are plotting the murder of King Duncan, when King Duncan is murdered, and when Macbeth, Lady Macbeth, and the lords are dining in the castle after Banquo is murdered. In the 1978 film, Lady Macbeth's susceptibility and emotional sensitivity is highly emphasized in all of the given scenes. She appears to be very nervous and obsessed about Macbeth's prophecy that he would become King of Scotland due to the fact that she is a very power-hungry woman (Crowther). Because of this, it seems very fitting that Macbeth reacts accordingly to her wishes and desires in a way that matches her emotional state. The 2010 film provides a noticeable amount of contrast to this. In the same scenes, Lady Macbeth is equally as obsessed in her desire for power, but she is more demonic and manipulating about it (Goold). Macbeth is more ruthless and cold-hearted as he, too, becomes a bloodthirsty killer just to keep his royal title
William Shakespeare’s masterpiece, Macbeth, is a tragedy brilliantly brought to the 21st Century by Rupert Goold. Although Shakespeare’s Macbeth is a play set in 16th Century Scotland, Rupert Goold modernizes the play by changing the setting to a Soviet-styled country and implementing modern elements into the characters and theme. Although Shakespeare’s Macbeth and Rupert Goold’s film adaptation share many ideologies and a general storyline, a difference exists in the setting, the characters, and the overall ambience of the story.
“Macbeth” by William Shakespeare and “A Tale Of Two Cities” by Charles Dickens are two classic pieces of literature with the most unforgettable stories and characters. Two characters included within these books are Madame Defarge of “A Tale Of Two Cities” and Lady Macbeth of “Macbeth” ,both posing as prevailing female characters. Madame Defarge has been created as a stong but unchanging character, whereas Lady Macbeth was formed as a stong but compelling character. Though these characters may be portrayed differently, they are developed the same way, through the same technique. In the books, “A Tale Of Two Cities” and “Macbeth”, the most common way the two characters, Lady Macbeth and Madame Defarge, were characterized was their attitudes and how their perspectives changed with given circumstance throughout the book. Though the two have traits on the opposite spectrum they both were developed the same way.
Lady Macbeth progresses throughout the play from a seemingly savage and heartless creature to a very delicate and fragile woman. In the beginning of the play, she is very ambitious and hungry for power. She pushes Macbeth to kill Duncan in order to fulfill the witches’ prophecy. In Act I, Scene 6, she asks the gods to make her emotionally strong like a man in order to help her husband go through with the murder plot. She says, “Come, you spirits That tend on mortal thoughts, unsex me here, And fill me, from the crown to the toe, top-full Of direst cruelty!” Also, she does everything in her power to convince Macbeth that he would be wrong not to kill Duncan. In Act I,
There was a clear distinction between the book, Macbeth and the 2010 version of the movie, Macbeth, but there were also some similarities included, to prove that it was still Macbeth. In contrast with the book, the movie took place closer to the present, beginning with a civil war and men using weapons that corresponded with its time period, which was fair for an interpretation. Conversely, I felt as though it lost some of its charm, because I truly believed that I, along with every single person who had read Macbeth, would have envisioned the setting to take place in an older period of time.
Macbeth is one of the many plays written by William Shakespear. It is considered as one of his greatest works for it's ever engaging story, Macbeth is also the most filmed/preformed of all of Shakespears' plays .‘Macbeth’ is set to be in Scotland; revolving around the main character, Macbeth. Macbeth's ambition leads him to commit murder after murder ; in order to be King.He first murders the former king, Duncan, his friend Banquo and later the family of the nobleman, Macduff.
Macbeth is a play about a Scottish general (Macbeth) who receives a prophacy from three witches that states that one day, he wil become the king of Scotland. This makes Macbeth power hungry so he decides to murder the current king of Scotland, Duncan. As people grow more and more suspicious of who killed Duncan, Macbeth is forced to commit more murders in order to protect himself from being exposed. This leads to him becoming filled with paranoia and guilt, which ultimately is his major downfall. Shakespeare wrote this play in 1606 to make people realize that excessive ambition can have terrible consequences. Both the play and the movie incorporate murders into telling the story of Macbeth, but they do so in different ways.
After the murder of Banquo, MacBeth hallucinates Banquo’s ghost at the table, And states that he cannot sit down because the table is full (3.4). I personally believe that Lady MacBeth was the ultimate reason for MacBeth’s mental deterioration, she played a key part in his decision-making when it came to his run in of power. This all leads up to the incompatibility of living a normal life, which led to the downfall of him being king.
In both plays, there was different methods to create drama. In both movies I watched, the drama was completely different. In Macbeth, one way that drama was created was when Macbeth stabbed another man in his sleep and some of the girls saw Macbeth killing King Duncan so that he could take the Scottish throne. Most people were not that happy with what Macbeth did because his actions were wrong and it created a bunch of drama with the people. Lady Macbeth started to feel the guilt of all the crime that her and her husband comminuted. Macbeth was stabbing King Duncan, Lady Macbeth had to take over Macbeth because Macbeth would not stop stabbing the King. There were rumors that Macbeth was going to have a couple people kill Banquo. So Banquo was trying to talk to Macbeth, but Macbeth had hired three men to kill Banquo so they did just that.
Although Lady Macbeth is still stronger and more ambitious than Macbeth the killing of Duncan is the point where the gap starts to narrow. She calls Macbeth a coward when he tries to back out of the plan and is the driving force that causes Macbeth to kill Duncan. She also shows strength when Macbeth returns from the murder and she tells him "These deeds must not be thought after these ways. So, it will make us mad". But when she has to go kill the guards she starts to lose some of her composure. Upon return to their room Lady Macbeth is just as shook up as Macbeth. This shows how Lady Macbeth is mostly talk and starts to weaken when the murders begin and the pressure sets in.
When comparing the book Macbeth by Shakespeare, and the movie Macbeth directed by Justin Kurzel a few differences occur. One difference being the order in which the witches presented in the novel and movie. In the book, the witches are presented in the first act and first scene, whereas the witches in the movie are shown after Macbeth’s fight scene. Also in this scene, the witches say the “Fair is foul and foul is fair” chant separately, whereas in the book the witches say this chant in unison at the end of the scene. The reasons behind these changes vary, from making more logical sense to other to how “creepy” the director could lay the movie out. Although in the book version of Macbeth the chant the witches say in unison makes more sense because of its purpose of foreshadowing for what later happens in Macbeth, the director uses this scene to incorporate a spooky feeling towards the beginning of the movie, primarily using their tones and physical appearance to portray the book, rather than using the meaning of the words to portray the book.
There are many differences between these two version of MacBeth, and each of them, I believe, serves it's own purpose to enhance and better the
Macbeth, is a film that was made in 2015 and was directed by Justin Kurzel. The screenplay used for the movie was written by Todd Louiso, Jacob Koskoff, and Michael Lesslie. On the other hand, the screenplay was adapted by William Shakespeare’s play Macbeth. William Shakespeare wrote this play back in 1606. The film and the play have some differences, some being small details that were just added by the writers of the screenplay. However, because this film is based on William Shakespeare’s play, there are also many similarities. A difference that stood out in the movie was the opening scene, where it shows a burial being held for what the audience can assume is Macbeth’s son. What I noticed throughout the film was that the storyline was based off of what was taking place in the movie (actions), rather than what
Rupert Goold`s brilliance was on full display the way he was able to make this film Macbeth, a huge success the way he interchanged the play's initial renaissance theme taking place in the 1600s. He recreated the play into a more modern day version, appealing to the viewer's understanding of what's taking place. While the characters conversed with each other in the same old school english wordplay. What I really found fascinating was how Lady Macbeth, played by Kate Fleetwood and her husband Macbeth, played by Patrick Stewart, dramatized their plots to steal the throne. The lust for power portrayed by both creates suspense in the sense that most of their peers were oblivious to their true intentions, as they go on about to eliminate anyones
To understand Shakespeare’s tragic play, Macbeth it is necessary to fully comprehend the characters of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth. The differences between Lady Macbeth and Macbeth are profound. Over the course of the play, Shakespeare skillfully changes the role of the two characters. Macbeth is frightened at the beginning then confident at the end while Lady Macbeth confident at the beginning and frightened at the end.
“Macbeth” a play written by William Shakespeare depicts how a courageous warrior Macbeth kills, King Duncan with the help of his wife in order to become the King of Scotland after the revelation of three prophecies from three witches that