Comparing The Factors of the Rise of Mussolini to Those of Hitler
A. Similarities:
Benito Mussolini
Adolf Hitler
Decisions of the Paris Peace Conference
Italy joined the First World War in 1915. Yet after the war Britain, France and other victorious allies did not fulfill their territorial promises as stated in the Treaty of London. Italians felt cheated. Since the Italian government failed to fight for the gains, it was deemed incompetent. Mussolini who promised revival of the glory of the ancient Roman Empire naturally got popular support.
Germany was the major defeated country of the First World War. She was forced to sign the harsh Treaty of Versailles. She was to lose large
…show more content…
It faced the problems similar to those of Italy. There were 9 cabinets in 1920-28. Moreover, Germany was unified by Bismarck. It inherited from Prussia the tradition of authoritarianism and contempt for democracy. German people were dissatisfied with the inefficient administration of the Weimar government. In addition, the Weimar Constitution vested too much power in the hands of the President, which increased the chance for Hitler to become a dictator.
Postwar Economic Difficulties
Production came to a halt in Italy after the war. Over one million people became unemployed. Besides, 2.5 million soldiers had returned and waited for jobs. Italy also owed a huge amount of war debts. There was hyper-inflation. Enterprises and factories closed down. The economy was going to collapse. People longed for a saviour.
Other than war debts, Germany was also burdened with the huge indemnity imposed by the Treaty of Versailles. No money was available for reconstruction. The mark dropped in value horribly when the French troops occupied the Ruhr district in 1923. Although Stresemann could overcome the economic hardship for the time being with American aid, the Great Depression of 1929 put Germany in an economic crisis again. By 1932 6 million people were unemployed. People had no hope for the Weimar Republic.
Threat of Communism
Some Italians were
Drawing similarities between the three is fairly effortless. Not only did Hitler and Mussolini both have an inadequate or an inferior upbringing, but they were also both raised Catholic. Mussolini, however, did finish his schooling, as did Emperor Hirohito. Emperor Hirohito evaded serving in the First World War
Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini are two of the most well-known leaders of the totalitarian movement which began in the 20th century. The early 1900’s was a very brutal time in history, as it commenced the beginning of the first world war. As young men, they both served as soldiers in World War One. Their involvement in the war both left them with violent views of socialism and communism. In the summer of 1919, the Treaty of Versailles was signed, marking the end of the war. The treaty forced Germany to accept sole responsibility for the war, resulting in global German humiliation. The consequences left Germany liable for harsh reparations and the reassignment of boundaries. Hitler's
The rulings of these two leaders had many similarities yet still had some differences. Their beliefs in running the country came to be very alike. Hitler and Mussolini both had negation of parliamentary and democratic political order, the use of violence and of physical strength, and the “revolutionary project” of a new society. Hitler and Mussolini feared any kind of strong and permanent power other than their own. This system of government where many institutions clashed with one another was extremely chaotic, and only the one leader could keep it working.
The rise of Fascism in Italy contributed to World War II because of it’s militaristic and nationalistic
This cause the beginning of Mussolini's rise in power, which also led to the agreement of peace between Italy and Germany.
At the signing of the Treaty of Versailles, Italy was excluded and treated as though it were a second rate country. After WWI the Italian people were left enraged and humiliated; Benito Mussolini promised to return them to their former glory, and the Italian people succumbed to the fascist ideology. The Italian people looked to resolve the anger over Versailles, the government chaos, and the communist issue. Benito Amilcare Andrea Mussolini was born into a poor Italian family on July 29th, 1883. His father was a blacksmith with socialist political views, so consequently, Benito was named after multiple famous socialists.
Government and politics- The rancor in the Germans, the fragility of the Weimar system, fear brought by soldiers in violent Nazi military groups, and Hitler’s intellectual speeches; is what encouraged Hitler’s rise to power. During the Great Depression in Germany, people wanted someone to fault, and searched for a way out- Hitler provided them with what they wanted. Germany and Italy were angry at the results of the Treaty of Versailles. Fascism gave them control, in all characteristics, of the state. Benito Mussolini was the first leader to establish Fascism. During the Great Depression the growth of population required tremendous food imports. The high tariffs and racism of other countries against Japan restricted the exporting of goods. Consequently, Japanese surmised that that broadening through armed acquisition would resolve Japans financial complications. This time of despair affected the US as well. Americans feared entering another war and therefore turned into isolationism.
The rulings of these two leaders had many similarities yet still had some differences. Their beliefs in running the country came to be very alike. Hitler and Mussolini both had negation of parliamentary and democratic political order, the use of violence and of physical strength, and the "revolutionary project" of a new society. Hitler and Mussolini feared any kind of strong and permanent power other than their own. This system of government where many institutions clashed with one another was extremely chaotic, and only the one leader could keep it working.
Both Hitler and Mussolini stressed on one-party dictatorship in order to secure their leading positions. The second similarity is that the two state leaders both took advantage of spies and the police force to monitor the behaviour of their citizens. In Germany, the SS (Schutzstaffel), SA (Sturmabteilung), SD (Sicherheitsdienst) and Gestapo (Secret Police State) together formed the political police force. They were allowed to enter and search private
Hitler and Mussolini both came in to power in the early days when their countries, Germany and Italy were facing problems after the Great War. Even then, both Hitler and Mussolini successfully gain and maintain power and control the country.
This downfall wounded Italy’s national pride, it led to depression and high unemployment rates; as well as a social unrest and an increase in street violence. As a result, Mussolini knew Italy needed a new doctrine in order to redeem itself. When world war one ended in 1919, Mussolini stated that “Socialism, as a doctrine, was already dead”, this influenced him to use national unity and order to create a new political movement known as fascism. Mussolini explained, “Fascism was not the nursling of a doctrine previously drafted at a desk, it was born of the need of action, and was an action … an anti-party and a movement.” Mussolini began with the creation of a band of young men, called the black shirts, who fought for national unity. These men would “fight both technical and spiritual rear-guirdism” and would not be “fainthearted”. As a response, Italy began giving Mussolini and his men financial support. On October 1922, his men mobilized through the parliamentary government, leading the king to declare Marshall law and making Mussolini the new leader of Italy. Now holding all the power in his hands, Mussolini marginalized the parliament. There was a destruction of organized labor and an elimination of all political parties except fascism. Fascism promoted the leader principle, which meant one leader would smooth over everyone, in this case Mussolini. He wanted dictatorship and violence was his way of achieving it. It enforced the ideology of action, it was ready to deal with all the problems by its own policies. Fascism was born from violent struggle and not politics, in this case violence was a good thing to Mussolini and he was all for it. Fascism did not believe in possibility nor utility of peace, any doctrine that promoted peace was contradicting fascist beliefs. It also opposed all doctrines of liberalism, which was the idea of
During the hardship of the 1920s and1930s, political incompetence was highlighted, the Weimar Government proved its incompetence time and time again. .The instability of the Weimar Republic was so great that the average life-span of Reich cabinets was from 6-7 months. Their incapability of providing justice to outbreaks of violence, such as political assassinations is one example of the incompetence of the Weimar Republic. When Germany found its self in undesirable economical situations due to the Treaty of Versalles, they printed money to pay off reparations, which resulted in super-inflation. During the period of super-inflation people’s life savings became worthless which contributed to the downward circle of a reduction in standard of living. As unemployment rose and people began to afford less and less with their money, people commenced searching for a better alternative to the Weimar Government. Hitler’s ability to build upon these feelings whilst offering security, prosperity and full employment, convinced Germany, in a state of disillusionment, to support the nazi party. The Weimar’s instability contributed to the collapse of the Weimar republic provided perfect conditions for the nazi party to rise to power.
The economic instability of Europe developed totalitarian goverments that began rising during the depression in the late 1920’s and early 1930’s. Germany, Italy, and Japan all became countries subjected to the rule of dictated military rule leaving no room for opposition. Benito Mussolini came to power in Italy in 1922 (Calvocoressi, Wint, p 777, 1999). Mussolini had his own philosophy that his destiny was to rule over Italy as Caesar in a more modern version while re-creating the Roman Empire. In his attempts in
Fundamentally, both Benito Mussolini and Adolf Hitler had the same burning desire to each make their nation a respected and economically impregnable Great Power. Mussolini wanted to return Italy to its glory days of the ancient Roman Empire, a domestic policy amongst others which was used as propaganda and to ultimately consolidate his power. A strong economy and a united state were vital for both countries in case of the outbreak of yet another catastrophic war. "Everything in the state, nothing outside the state, nothing against the state", stated Mussolini in need of desperate backup at home. Post WWI left both Germany and Italy with grave problems economically, which further repelled into social problems such as high unemployment and
Benito Mussolini returned to Italy claiming to “bring back Italy’s pride and make Italy a well-respected state again” (“Fascism,” n.d.). Mussolini wanted to solve Italy’s economic issues as well and pushed for a strong, national leader that could unite the people. Mussolini’s ideas appealed to Italian citizens because Mussolini wanted to solve, or at least claimed to, all the problems they were facing at the time. Mussolini began “delivering emotional speeches” in attempt to increase supporters, and in 1919, Mussolini established the first fascist regime in Italy (Martz, 2010). The Fascist Party gained a lot of attention and support because they blamed the unfair outcome of the war on the current, weak Italian democracy (Pollard, 2004, p. 29). Citizens easily put the blame on the liberal politicians and sought refuge from the opposing right wing political groups. Italy was very susceptible to Mussolini’s Fascist rule and ideologies because Italy was desperate for a change and solution to their instability. Martz (2010) states that Benito Mussolini’s charisma was a major contributor in establishing his support base and “a powerful fascist state.” Mussolini began to promote the idea that the “common will” of the people came before the will of the individual. Mussolini ensured that the citizens’ sacrifice and devotion to Italy was the only way to achieve true stability and unity (Martz, 2010). Mussolini’s charisma allowed him to easily