preview

Comparing Film And The Tell-Tale Heart

Decent Essays

Some novels are turned into movies, just like how some short stories are turned into a film; in films, a director usually cannot include every single detail that a book can. In a movie, the audience has a harder time using their imagination, because the director is basically telling the story from their point of view. In a book/novel, the author has the ability to describe/write with the reader in mind. They want to feed the reader just enough information so the reader can use their imagination. In the short story “The Tell-Tale Heart” and The Tell-Tale Heart (1941) are alike thus far different in many ways. Imaginations can change and create a different view for each member of the audience. In the short story “The Tell-Tale Heart”, Edgar …show more content…

This feeling can cause a person to reanalysis their situation to understand and chooser the proper choice in their situation. The story differentiates from the film. In the story “The ringing became more distinct: —it continued… but it continued and gained definitiveness” (Poe 8); which is a result of his conscious telling him what he did was not tolerable and reminding him every second that he should give himself up to stop the beating in his ears. The noise ultimately became too much for the young man to bear and he wanted the ‘ringing’ noise to stop; thus, he told the police the truth and where he hid the old man’s body and to “tear up the planks” (Poe 8). While in the film The Tell- Tale Heart (1941) the young man’s action help tell the police that something was not correct (The Tell-Tale Heart (1941) 13:05). His actions at this point of the story portrayed that of a mad man and he showed all the signs of a guilty conscience (The Tell-Tale Heart (1941) 8:46); this resulted in the police to press harder and harder on him to cause him to break. At the end of the film, he ends up giving himself up and telling the police “to tear up the planks” (The Tell-Tale Heart (1941) 17:43). The pounding was an example of self-conscience happening in both the story and film, but it happened through different actions of the police and the young

Get Access