preview

Compare And Contrast Sa Adi With Whitman

Decent Essays

Ahmadsoltani (2009) compares Sa’adi with Whitman. The author believes that purpose of poetry for the two poets was not the same, but they both were successful in dealing with social subjects. Sympathy, justice, prosperity and life are among the common subjects in the two poets.
Payande (2009) compares Whitman's “When I Heared the Learn'd Astronomer” with Sepehri's “Sorah of Watching”. The poets believe that reason is unable to find out the essence of being. Payande pays attention to the similarities rather than the influences, and believes trying to trace influences is useless. The ideas of Sepehri and Whitman are so similar that Stovall's comment on the American poet quoted in the article best fits Sepehri.
Miller (2009) compares Whitman with …show more content…

The authors believe that the American poet was involved in religion as a subject of his works and that he treated the subject very seriously. Not only was he familiar with Emerson’s works on the oriental poets but also he read some of those poets in translation. The writers try to illustrate the similarities between Whitman’s religious beliefs and Sufism. The three poets’ “egotism” was rooted in their belief in God's omnipresence. Another significant feature that these three poets had in common was employing a secular language to deliver a spiritual message. Unconventional symbolism was still another common …show more content…

“Although Neo-Pragmatist scholars have long considered Walt Whitman an intellectual and literary forebear to William James and the American Pragmatic tradition, James believed Whitman to be a far more problematic thinker than has been acknowledged” (526). Whitman is present in much of James’s writings, and The Varieties of Religious Experience (1902) in particular. That Whitman is “embodiment of a particular kind of metaphysical excess, at once unworldly and effeminate” (526). Examining the writings of the leading gay Whitmanites of his era, James traced Whitman’s influence—both implicitly and explicitly. A “feminine” and “unnatural” Whitman was a chief foil to the father of Pragmatism. James defined “his own ‘manly’ beliefs and methodologies, particularly with respect to religious experience” (525) in contrast to that

Get Access