preview

Compare And Contrast Didion And Thomas

Decent Essays

There are always two sides to every story, sometimes even more. When discussing the phenomenon of the Santa Ana winds and their accompanying brush fires, Linda Thomas and Joan Didion each have their own side of the story. Throughout the texts, Didion and Thomas converge with one another by means of their life experiences as southern Californians and also through using sensory details to illustrate their stories. However, they do not share similar feelings towards the nature of the winds and fire. The authors diverge in this way as well as in their viewpoints on the conflict of people and nature. Through these similarities and differences, both Didion and Thomas build their respective messages into well written texts. Didion and Thomas share …show more content…

Didion uses it as a phrase of fear and anxiousness but Thomas manages to take away the fear affiliated with smoke and fire and turns it into a thing of beauty. At this point the texts diverge from one another in their viewpoints of brush fires. That forewarning of danger in The Santa Ana comes into play throughout the text, but especially lives up to its full potential in paragraph 5, "At the first prediction of a Santa Ana, the Forest Service flies men and equipment from northern California into the southern forests, and the Los Angeles Fire Department cancels its ordinary non-firefighting routines" (Didion). This fact coupled with statistics such as "on the first day 25,000 acres of the San Gabriel Mountains were burning" exemplifies the potential damage that the brush fires are capable of. On the contrary, in Brush Fire, Thomas describes the environment and the natural wildlife of the area that can be found in the "chaparral", a local name for the "vast expanses of low-lying brush". She then goes on to explain the necessity of the brush fires to the biome, "Some plants in the chaparral--such as the padre's staff-- require the heat of the flame to crack open their seed pods and prepare for germination" (Thomas). Fire is vital to the existence and survival of the padre's staff. Even though not all plant life in the chaparral zones need the heat to germinate, they still benefit from the …show more content…

In Brush Fires, Thomas points out that chaparral has been there since before people settled the area and, "the burning of chaparral during these winds is natural" (Thomas). She argues that the chaparral zone should take precedent over suburban development in her sixth paragraph, "All of this would be no more than the stuff of natural history...Right in the path of natural fires" (Thomas). Her stance on the matter is clear: homes being burned to the ground are not the fault of the fires, but of the moronic humans who built them in the middle of a known chaparral zone. Didion, however, does not agree. She argues that the fires are destroying homes in a sense of uncontrollable doom in the aforementioned paragraph 5, "The Santa Ana caused Malibu to burn as it did in 1956, and Bel Air in 1961, and Santa Barbara in 1964" (Didion). Didion believes that the brush fires of the Santa Ana winds are an obstacle to people due to the bad vibes and horrible fires they bring. Whereas, Thomas believes that the encroaching human population is the obstacle to the natural brush fires that are just running their

Get Access