Compare And Contrast Antigone And King's Views On Civil Disobedience

Overall, Antigone’s choices fit into Thoreau’s philosophy regarding civil disobedience. In Thoreau's work, “Civil Disobedience,” Thoreau makes points that clearly justify Antigone’s actions. One such case is when Antigone goes to give her brother a proper burial. Another one of these cases occurs when Antigone is put into jail for being honorable. Finally, an example of Thoreau’s idea of civil disobedience is epitomized when Antigone refuses allegiance to a government that she views as unjust. According to Thoreau, Antigone’s actions were just when she went to bury her brother despite Creon decreeing that no can do so. By burying her brother, she refuses to obey an unjust law. Antigone’s entrapment in the tomb fits into Thoreau’s

Civil disobedience is defined as the refusal to obey the demands or certain laws of a government/ occupying power. Without resorting to violence or active events of conflict, it is typically used in the form of a peaceful protest. Civil disobedience has been seen in historical context as a main approach and philosophy of nationalist movements in Africa, India, and also in the American civil rights movement. It can also be a useful tactic in labor, anti-war, and other social movements occurring in numerous countries around the world. In both Sophocles’ Antigone and Martin Luther King, Jr.’s Letter from a Birmingham Jail, the author describes two very different displays of civil disobedience. Antigone disobeyed “man’s law” and buried her brother. Martin Luther King, Jr., on the other hand, fought to change the law for the rights of a large group of people. For this reason, Martin Luther King, Jr.’s efforts were more admirable than the efforts of Antigone.

Within Letter from a Birmingham Jail, MLK describes the four-step plan one must follow to carry on a nonviolent campaign. Antigone’s actions throughout Antigone carefully mimic those steps. Throughout the story you can consider Antigone’s actions to be part of a nonviolent campaign. MLK says that, “In any nonviolent campaign there are four basic steps: collection of the facts to determine whether injustices exist; negotiation; self-purification; and direct action” (paragraph six). Antigone determined there was an injustice committed when Creon’s edict decreed that no one would be able to bury her brother Polyneices or they face a punishment by death. Antigone finds this to be an injustice, when she asks for help from her sister Ismene she says, “…And now you can prove what you are: A true sister, or a traitor to your family.” (Antigone 26-27). Once captured by the Sentry she negotiates with Creon, attempting to appeal to him so he is able to understand her reverence for the dead is what god wants (lines 355-420). Within self-purification Antigone undergoes strong emotions that could be alluded to feelings of suicide and depression. All she wants is to bury Polyneices and not let this injustice go unnoticed. She is willing to go to great lengths to fight for what she believes in and the extent she goes to stand up for what she believes is the act of self-purification MLK talks about. Her direct action is

Moral? Or Immoral? Those are questions that unconsciously go through a human’s mind when he or she makes decisions in everyday life. Some, however, may wonder where the boundaries are set. Most people believe that they have these restrictions on what is moral or immoral based off of experience or just by a “gut feeling.” Through the texts, Antigone and a “Letter from a Birmingham Jail,” readers see the conflict that arises concerning the idea of morality. Both Antigone and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. expressed their ideas on the topic; they agreed that the line was drawn when a direct family member or group of people were placed in danger or were wronged. The two characters’ actions were shaped by individuals like Kreon and the “white moderates” of the city of Birmingham. Antigone battled with Kreon to obtain justice for her late brother, while Dr. King criticized the citizens who were content with abiding to questionable laws to not break the peace. Their modes of action, however, were different. Antigone handled the disagreement by herself, while Dr. King utilized the power of many to make his point clear.

The first step in Martin Luther King Jr.’s nonviolent campaign is collection of facts to determine whether injustices are alive, which is what Antigone does when hearing about the death of both of her brothers.

In Sophocles’ Antigone and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail”, Antigone and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. used resistance against powerful leaders to follow their morals and make a statement. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s approach towards the reconstruction of society’s cultural understanding of segregation used civil disobedience in a more public and large-scale approach, whereas Antigone’s use of civil disobedience defied the law in a much more private, small-scale way to do what she believed what was right. Compared to Antigone, Dr. King’s approach was more strategic and planned out. In addition to Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s advocacy for equal treatment and Antigone’s dedication to obey the gods, they used

In Sophocles, Antigone, translated by Ruby Blondell, the main character, Antigone, rebelled against the unethical treatment of her brothers, while Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. also rebelled against the unethical treatment of African Americans in the United States in the 1950s and 1960s. Both Antigone and King Jr. sacrificed their lives to highlight the unethical and unjust treatment in their societies. However, King Jr. uses civil disobedience to achieve his goals to end inequality for African Americans in the United States and is assassinated, while Antigone uses her religion as motivation to bury her brothers and ultimately commit suicide as she so strongly disapproves the actions which the King of Thebes, Kreon. King Jr.’s tactics were more effective than Antigone’s as King Jr. was able to pave the way for equality for African Americans in the United States, while Antigone’s tactics only left Creon to feel guilty and led to no change in her society.

Antigone and Dr. Martin Luther king demonstrate that breaking laws that are unjust can be a good thing by bringing reform. Their nonviolent approach of civil disobedience till this day leave an impact on how we go about social injustice. Through their actions and words, both Antigone, and Dr. Martin Luther king demonstrate that they are not afraid to die for their beliefs and inspire us to take a passive approach towards the social injustices we are faced by in our community. I sympathize more with Dr. Martin Luther King because I believe that he took a more logical approach in stopping social injustice, as well as the fact that he is willing to put his life on the line for a whole community of people, in contrast to Antigone who is willing to die for solely her brother.

Exploration of Civil Disobedience in Sophocles' Antigone, King's Letter from Birmingham Jail, and Plato's From Crito

In life, humanity has the responsibility to adhere to the rules and regulations imposed upon it by a superior power. For the most part, this obedience breeds peaceful order and mutual understanding; however, when the body in control grows corrupt and enforces unjust laws, the people rightfully turn their thoughts to revolt. This is the case with Antigone, who was correct in her rejection of the inhumane ordinance proclaimed by King Creon. Her means are justified by her desperation to please the gods, her desire to honor her fallen brother, and her compulsion to perform what is morally right.

Antigone defies the law of King Creon to honor her brother with a proper burial. She willingly goes against the King to follow the law of the gods’ regardless of the consequences, doing what she believes is right. Similarly, Martin Luther King travels to Birmingham to march and protest the injustices towards Black people because he believed it is the right thing to do. Although Antigone was not afraid to die for what she believed in, Martin Luther King’s method of civil disobedience was more effective because Antigone failed to promote negotiations and just accepted her punishment freely. King believed that to properly have a nonviolent approach towards injustice you must be able to speak peacefully to gain understanding for negotiation. Urging people to create tension in the form of civil disobedience to promote awareness of the injustices.

Throughout history, there has been those who fight for what they believe in and those who counterstrike these efforts. While the opposers may seem like the villains in the story, it is always possible to liberate them. These sentiments are mirrored in the ideas of both Nelson Mandela’s “Long Walk to Freedom” and Sophocles’ “Antigone.” Mandela’s commitment to the liberation of not only those who are oppressed, but those who have acted as their oppressors is one that can be found in a number of different narratives. Antigone proves Mandela’s ideas regarding oppression through her determination and refusal to submit to Creon’s tyrannical rulings, which lead to his personal liberation and self-reflection by the close of the piece.

Justice is the process result of using law to fairly judge and punish a crime or a criminal. Injustice is the lack of fairness and justice. Martin Luther King Jr. led the civil rights movement. This movement was a mass popular movement to secure equal access and opportunities for the basic privileges and rights of U.S. citizenship to all the people living in America. The act was active between 1955 and 1968. King was famous for using nonviolent resistance to overcome injustice, and he never got tired of trying to end segregation laws. In 1963 Martin Luther King Jr. was arrested and sent to jail because he and others were protesting the treatment of blacks in Birmingham, Alabama. A court had ordered that King could not hold protests in Birmingham. While King was in jail, he wrote a letter, “Letter From Birmingham Jail”, to the newspaper explaining why he had broken the law. In the book, “Antigone” by Sophocles, similar events had happened to the main character, Antigone. Creon, the king of Thebes, had ordered for no one to mourn over the death of Polynices, son of Oedipus (the former king of Thebes who unwittingly killed his father and married his mother), there was to be no type of burial or prayers for him. If anyone was to try and touch the body of Polynices there was to be sentenced to death. Antigone played a bigger role than Creon in that she defied the law and started the whole play’s chain of events, eventually leading to nearly everyone’s death. Regardless Ismene’s, her sister, warning to listen to the king’s edict, Antigone gave her brother a burial, prayers and poured ritual wine on the corpse. Martin Luther King Jr. and Antigone both had fought for something they believed in, something that went against the law and both were punished for their ‘crime’.

The two of them are fighting for better justice for people as a whole. An example of this would be Antigone fighting for her brothers body to be moved out of the open are and to be covered. King is fighting for equal rights, for people of color to have a chance in life and to be treated as an equal to the white man. I think that Antigone was rebelling against the general idea of the dead being treated like her brother had been. " I cannot side with hatred. My nature sides with love," (Sophocles 13). Second, Antigone is the best to come up against King because she was willing to essentially sacrifice her life for the service of a greater kind of justice. Within the text we see Antigone give up her time to be put in jail and to be faced with death. Isn 't this exactly what King did. King made it his life to teach others of justice and to bring about justice for the greater good and was killed for it. "Be brave. You are alive. Already my soul is dead. It has gone to help those who died before me," (Sophocles 13). Third, Antigone used nonviolent action to bring about justice, just as King advocated for in his writing. Antigone didn 't tear through the city and begin bringing physical unrest, she stood my her position of what she believed justice was and did it in a peaceable way. This is a big thing to be found in Kings writing. "Nonviolent direct action seeks to create such a crisis and foster such a tension that a community which has constantly refused to negotiate

Although civil disobedience rarely accomplishes the change that it demands directly, it does create change indirectly through raising awareness and support. Civil disobedience works by relying on the reaction of governments/societies after individuals rebel to rally support for the protest. If the government/society violently crushes the rebellion, as in the case of Antigone, then the civil disobedience wins by creating pity and sorrow for the rebellion. However, if the government/society does not react, then the individuals are still successful by being allowed to get away with acts of civil disobedience which spread their cause.