preview

Clean, Well-Lighted Place

Decent Essays

The contrast between light and dark has consistently served to portray contrast, whether it be between black and white, fulfillment and loss, or, most importantly, good and evil. Throught the short story a Clean, Well-Lighted place, by Ernest Hemingway, a conversation between two bartenders is depicted. Each bartender has different views on not only the old, deaf man drinking at the bar but about what everything and nothing mean to them. The usage of light and dark as symbols in a Clear, Well-Lighted Place depict different perspectives on comfort, what it means to be alone, and the true definition of everything and nothing. The younger waiter in the cafe longs to be home in bed next to his wife, and insists the old man sitting at the window …show more content…

The discussion between the two waiters highlights the difference in perspectives on what having everything truly means. The younger waiter demonstrates his lack of insight about the drunken man’s situation: “‘Last week he tried to commit suicide,” one waiter said… “He was in despair.” “What bout?” “Nothing.” “How do you know it was nothing?” “He has plenty of money.”” (Hemingway, 1). The younger waiter assumes that because the old man has plenty of money, he has nothing to be in despair about, and therefore has no motive to commit suicide. The older waiter, however, does not believe that having plenty of money means that the old man can’t be in despair. This quote demonstrates the contrasting views of the two waiters about what it means to have everything. The older waiter assures the younger that he has everything: “‘You have youth, confidence, and a job,” the older waiter said. “You have everything.”’ (Hemingway, 2). The older waiter feels that having everything does not mean solely having money- it involves having a purpose, or a reason to live. For the younger waiter, the old man’s life seems ideal. The younger waiter does not understand that the old man does not feel like he has somewhere to go home to. He goes as far as to say that the old man should have killed himself the past week so that he wouldn’t need to work past two a.m. and can return

Get Access