preview

Claim 1-044: A Case Study

Satisfactory Essays

Claim(s) 1-15 are not fairly based because they travel beyond the subject matter described in the specification. The attorney’s submission filed on 22 October 2015 has been fully considered, but it is not persuasive. From reading the specification as a whole, the invention lies in achieving the result of manufacture metal vessel from metal sheet stamping. However, the claims embrace the method to achieve the result of the first and second vessel halves having a wall thickness equal to the initial thickness of the metal sheet. However, the whole specification does not describe the best method of performing the invention; although in paragraph 044 disclose the objective of the invention is to achieve the final wall thickness of the vessel

Get Access