I am pretty safe to assume that everyone can acquiescently admit that this is a topic is something everyone both agrees and disagrees with; however, it’s something that depends on the situation can be a pro or con. Still, I believe that it’s a pro situation if it’s dealt with correctly. Doing what’s right. Doing the just thing. That’s what everyone is taught to believe and follow by. Isn’t it more humane to want to solve things rationally? Why not just try to be more human rather than brutes? Civil Disobedience is a method of nonviolent rebellion that causes people to look at what’s taking place around them, and realize that there is no equality around them. Seeing that great actions have been taken place with success, it’s fair …show more content…
Now, civil disobedience isn’t a common thing that occurs anymore, and people then ask the question “what is a civil disobedience action?” Well, a recent example of a modern day civil disobedience example is the transgender bill that was in the legislature not too long ago. This caused a protest that didn’t become violent with the Transgenders in South Dakota. The protest started when this bill was made public, but still passed for a brief amount of time before the governor came to realize its unjust qualities. Many transgender students in South Dakota gave the governor complimentary remarks when he denied this bill, and exclaimed that if this topic were to rise again they’d just fight back again. This was in fact a modern form of civil disobedience, and a connection of this situation to you as a person to grasp a real understanding of this topic.
“You must be the change you wish to see in the world.” Mohandas Gandhi. Gandhi, a man thought of as a legend, has humanity looking back on his work in history and has influenced and changed cultures around the world. An act that Gandhi has made an impact on the world with was his famous Salt March in the 1930s. In order to win India its freedom from the British control Gandhi broke the law that no one was allowed to make salt at the sea’s shore. Gandhi’s method of philosophy was called Utilitarianism. Utilitarianism
Civil Disobedience is defined as refusal to obey civil laws or decrees, which usually takes the form of direct action (Grolier’s Encyclopedia Online 2). Thoreau wrote that people practicing civil disobedience, break a law because they consider the law unjust. People want to call attention to its injustice. Thoreau voiced civil disobedience as, “An expression of the individual’s liberty to create change” (Thoreau 530). Years later Martin Luther King Jr. took the same idea of direct action to protest the injustices brought upon black Americans in the United States. One major example was the Birmingham bus boycott. Blacks where treated unjust and often had to give up their seats to whites, and had to listen to racial slurs made by the bus driver. King like Thoreau, did not take a violent approach, he often used sit-ins and rallies to unite the black community (Encarta
Civil disobedience is the refusal to obey laws, in hopes to get them changed for the better of humanity/ civilization of that specific or general community. Malala Yousafzai is a great example of civil disobedience. The whole reason she was shot in 2012 was because she dared to ‘fight’ back against the taliban by going to school and trying to make other countries aware of the harm that the taliban was causing to the homes and lives of her people.
Civil disobedience is defined by the Merriam-Webster Dictionary as "a refusal to obey governmental commands especially as a nonviolent means of protest."(Jacobus) We can see an example of this in U.S. history, when this theory was applied during the Civil Right Movement. The laws back then restricted African Americans from being able to attend public schools or use public restrooms that were designated as "white only." Even though they had paid taxes like everyone else, these types of segregation laws targeted minorities and made them second-rate citizens. Martin Luther King, who was sincere in exposing
To me, civil disobedience is not following the rules or going against the rules especially if a rule you think is wrong or unjust and a good example of protest that happened recently is the protest outside of the Starbucks . Well, I also agree with your concept that everyone has the equal rights and that the civil disobedience is "disobedience to the
I believe civil disobedience is the refusal to obey certain laws, usually without violence, but only if it’s to make a point. In Thoreau’s essay about civil disobedience, there were points made which I agreed with, but there were things that I disagreed with. Some points he made that I agreed with was that if someone wants something to change, they should do something and do it wholeheartedly. An additional point he made which I agreed with was to depend and think for one’s self. While he’s made points which I agreed with, there’s one I didn’t which was when he said that the military was programmed to do whatever the government says.
Civil Disobedience is the peaceful act of protesting a law between the civilians and government. Henry Thoreau explains it like this "… honest men to rebel and revolutionize" (page 392). In civil disobedience by Henry Thoreau he is explaining how the government of his time is abusing its power and people and how the people should do as he did and be a civil disobedient when the laws and government are unjust and go against a man's conscience. Thoreau wants the readers to peacefully protest the laws they feel are unjust, be aware of his own conscience, not be a puppet of the government, and not support anything that is of wrong-doing. He tells the readers to act and not just stand by passively or at least stop supporting what they feel is wrong, and I do believe he presents an effective argument for his point, and as accordingly it appeals to the common man.
Civil disobedience has been an act practiced by free societies across the globe. It has been a highly controversial topic in the Unites States over the years, as some believe the so-called "peaceful resistance" exemplifies too much defiance to the government. However, most believe that performing civil disobedience exercises many rights incorporated in the Constitution. Civil disobedience positively impacts a free society by allowing its citizens to express their opinions in a matter which draws the attention of the government, and heightens public awareness.
Civil disobedience is a belief that is practiced in which the people disobey the law in a peaceful manner because it does not come to an agreement with their moral values. Over the years this idea of challenging the government has developed into a duty for the people. This concept is explained in the piece “Civil Disobedience” by Henry David Thoreau and “Letter from Birmingham Jail” by Martin Luther King Jr. They both express acts of passive resistance in which the impact is still felt in the modern world. Although, these ideologies were used in Thoreau and King’s time, they need to be updated to fit in today’s world.
Civil Disobedience is a practice that's being used as far back as times of discrimination against blacks in the south. Even though slavery had been completely gotten rid of in the United States, the south still hated blacks with a passion. This led to the creation of Jim Crow laws, laws that looked as though they were helping blacks but really hurt them. Blacks had finally had enough and decided they would try and get equal rights one way or another, so they started politely disobeying the laws. In the 50's, a black man named Homer Adolph Plessy sat in a white train car because of the law he heard about, "Equal protection under the law" and he was arrested for doing so. This led to the creation of the "Separate but Equal" law.
Throughout American history are many examples of civil disobedience, and when we analyze the meaning of civil disobedience we realize that without this America would be a very different place. The Boston Tea Party, The Revolutionary War, The Civil Rights Movement are all a few major examples of civil disobedience that have shaped America into the world it is today. Civil disobedience, in a sense, is taking the law into ones own hands when they feel that the laws in place are unjust or unethical and want to change these laws to better ones own life and those of others. Sadly though, there are many lives on this Earth that cannot take the law into their hands, stand up for their rights, and change things for the better, and those lives are the
Civil disobedience is the active, professed refusal to obey certain laws, demands, and commands of a government, or of an occupying international power respectfully. I believe that this is good for a country as long as it is done peacefully and respectfully. It helps our country to see what is wrong with our laws, government, and country. One of the most famous examples of civil disobedience is when Rosa Parks was arrested for not giving up her seat on a bus to a white person. At this time black people were being segregated against. The law required that black people had to give up their seat for white people. This law was obviously morally wrong and unfair. Rosa Parks knew that refusing to give her seat up was against the law. However, she
The core of civil disobedience is an active refusal of certain government demands - whether they be laws, rulings, or mindsets. In practice, people violate unjust laws and accept consequences in order to demonstrate the injustice of said legislation. Often construed as rejection of the legal system, civil disobedience actually the opposite; the belief that government
If we take a closer look at civil disobedience, we can better understand what it means, its goals, and its outcomes. Civil disobedience predominantly exists as direct and non-violent government defiance. Instead of voicing an opinion with a vote or a simple conversation, civil disobedience stands up for what is right using an individual’s whole influence. Therefore, some sacrifices regarding the legality of actions are made in order to preserve the integrity of the mission. In other words, why should a protester follow the law that they are trying to alter? That doesn’t make much sense, therefore civil disobedience allows unjust laws to be broken for the greater good. This method is very effective if, for example, a minority is attempting to
Civil Disobedience is a right that is afforded to all people. When Civil Disobedience is used as a method of getting your point across to the government and law officials it is ok although when things turn violent and get out of control then that is when it is bad. Carl Cohen feels that Civil Disobedience is a method that condones going against authority and promotes violence while Henry Thoreau believe that Civil Disobedience is a great way to draw attention to the wrongs that need to be made right. I believe that everyone should have the right to express themselves without fear of negative response. Recently here in Charlotte NC with the death of Lamont Scott, who was believed to be an unarmed black man killed by a cop, there was Civil
What is civil disobedience? Civil disobedience is the opposing of a law one finds unjust by refusing to follow it and accepting the consequences. So many people have performed acts of civil disobedience from Martin Luther King Jr. to everyday people. But what people did as civil disobedience a hundred years ago is completely different today. It is such an important part of a free society because it helps to define what a free society is, shows the true meaning of freedom of speech, and shows the government that citizens are not willing to follow an unjust law without violence.