preview

Childhood Experiments

Decent Essays

The research in this report is a slight reproduction of the experiments conducted by Vosniadou and Brewer (1992) and Panagiotaki, Nobes and Banerjee (2006). The purpose of both of these studies were to investigate the nature of children’s knowledge about the earth’s shape (Vosniadou and Brewer, 1992) and their understanding of the earth, with the use of drawings and multiple questions types (Vosniadou et al., 1992; Panagiotaki, Nobes and Banerjee, 2006). Likewise the research conducted in this study was based in the area of childhood cognition and investigating the development to a child’s conceptual knowledge of the earth and its shape.
In Vosniadou et al’s (1992) study, they were interested in children’s initial knowledge of the earth’s …show more content…

Their study not only included children, but also adults, who were presented with a number of pictures and were asked to rank in order, how well they represented the earth (pg. 51). The research did not use the approach of asking children to draw, nor repeating questions to the children, as they believed that it would reduce the chance of their being ambiguity or misinterpretation with the final results (pg. 51). Their results stemmed from the research, believing that the adult participants would respond in a “scientific” manner, and that by comparing the children’s responses to the adults, they would be able to assess the extent to which a child viewed the earth in a scientific or adult-like manner (pg. …show more content…

In their study, they note that other research has led to varying conclusions of children’s understanding of the earth – this being, that some studies show that children “…construct their own non-scientific theories...” (pg. 432) and others indicate that many have some scientific understanding of the earth, but their knowledge lacks coherence. Similar to the previous research, Frède et al. (2011) tested with the different question types (open and forced-choice), and had a form of representations of the earth (2D pictures or 3D models), to examine how they would have an influence on the answers (scientific or non-scientific) given by children (pg. 435). Their results showed that similar to previous research, the forced-choice questions produced higher proportions of scientific answers from children than the open

Get Access