Mexican-American women, sometimes referred to as “Chicanas,” are oftentimes expected to be submissive daughters and ultimately wives, as the ownership of their bodies is passed from father to husband. From how they dress to whether or not they wear makeup to even the length of their hair is commonly controlled by their fathers and husbands. They are expected to fill their gender role as a caregiver---a mother---to serve their children and their husbands.
This differs from the cultural oppression faced by other minority women. Education is not seen as a priority for Mexican-American women as it is for Asian-American women; marriage and the family unit are seen as more important. The treatment of Mexican-American women also differs from the
…show more content…
Esperanza refers to this when she speaks of how she and her siblings grow up. She says, “The boys and the girls live in separate worlds” (Cisneros 12). Nancy Chodorow, sociologist and psychoanalyst, explains that boys and girls are at first are socialized similarly and have an attachment to their mothers. Chodorow argues that children tend to identify with the gender of the parent that identifies with them most closely; she states that mothers tend to identify with their daughters more than their sons. In the novel, this can be seen as Esperanza is depicted interacting almost exclusively with older women whether it be her mother, an aunt, or a neighbor. She has little interactions with her father, other men, and even boys; she even shares that she fears them (Cisneros 49). This further validates the gender hierarchy in place in Chicano culture. These interactions between parent (or anyone contributing to their socialization) and child that aid in gender identification can cause boys to later negatively repress any feelings of femininity in order to be perceived masculine like their fathers (Chodorow 87). This, then in turn can serve as the explanation of the common subordination of women, specifically in Mexican-American culture. On Mango Street, even as children, Esperanza’s younger brothers, don’t speak with her and …show more content…
Once Chicanas dress or appear “womanly”, they are objectified. Chicanas are shamed for being sexual beings. When Esperanza develops a crush on a boy, Sire, her family disapproves saying that he is a “punk” and not to talk to him (Cisneros 49). She is unable to explore her sexuality because her parents understand the validity of the gendered hierarchy and how her body is not her own. Sally’s father sexualizes her as she is beaten when she is seen speaking to boys; he says she is not his daughter and she is reminded of the “shame” her sisters brought by leaving home, presumably with men (Cisneros 59). Sally is shamed and punished for exploring her sexuality. The boys she experiments with treat her as less and objectify her because of her vulnerability. She ultimately escapes her father by marriage to man who treats her similarly to how her father did (Cisneros 64). When Chicana girls develop sexually and go through puberty, they become women in the sense that they are sexualized and shamed for feelings and body development that are normalized for their male counterparts (Lee
Anzaldua discusses the obstacles that come with being a Mexican American woman, explaining the cultural tyranny in Mexican American communities, like those portrayed in Chayo’s letter. Anzaldua writes, “Culture is made by those in power- men. Males make the rules and laws; women transmit them” (1018). Deviating from the norms of society by neither being a wife or a mother leads to the degradation and isolation of women since they are expected to act a certain
Young Chicana women typical expectations are to follow the parents’ rules. In the films “Mosquita Y Mari” and “Real Women have curves”, the young Chicana women resist these gender cultural norms. The resistance of these gender norms is not a challenge to others but away to voice the opinion that I am my own person and not somebody else.
Since than Chicanas have been accused for being traders and have been oppress by society. The author analyzed the roles Chicanas play in Mexican families and how they follow patriarchy views. For example, the mother in the story is describes as unworthy, week and insignificant within the family. However, Mama Luna as well as the young Chicana are being projected otherwise independent, smart, strong, and confident. Viramontes in her story she represents them as warrior Chicanas fighting against the conquistadores that killed many and took away our history.
Throughout the book, it is evident that predominantly only the observations and perspectives of Anglo-American males were presented rather than the ones belonging to native Latinos men which, arguably, can be problematic as the audience is only exposed to what Americans have to say on Mexican- American culture adaptation. This exclusion of the native voice can especially be seen at the section regarding targeting women as the crucial point in infiltrating the Mexican home with Americanized ideals. According to Sanchez, during 1915, there was a clear mindset that thought the “housekeeper creates the atmosphere” in the family and should “the female adopt American values, the rest of her family would follow” (Sanchez 99). Home teachers were told to teach women songs in English about the duty of women such as “…like to wash, to sew, to cook”. Yet, after six years, women stilled lacked behind men in English skills which, were seen as the a crucial part of Americanization. Unsurprisingly, the lack of success in the Americanization of women was perceived to be the “patriarchal nature of the Mexican Family”(Sanchez 101). Disappointingly, Sanchez did not include the Mexican female voice into this section, which could have provided more insights on how the women themselves felt about the Americanization programs and how they perceived the roles they played within their family, as he felt that professors such as Emory Bogardus (Sanchez 101) from University of Southern California has a more right to talk about Mexicano family structure than the Mexicans
In several cultures, women are seen as archetypes more than men. The proposition of women are instantly idealized and glorified and instantaneously ignore the true complexity of a woman. Countless of these superficial images can be seen across various cultures where the societies within these cultures define what it means to be a female and what type of behavior is and isn’t acceptable within those parameters. The persistent restatement of these stories throughout these generations reinforces the gender system. Women who step out of the norm in these societies are then held punishable for their actions. Alicia Gaspar de Alba pinpoints the three archetypal roles that are given to the women in the Mexican and Chicana cultures. These are,
The story illustrates the overlapping influences of women’s status and roles in Mexican culture, and the social institutions of family, religion, economics, education, and politics. In addition, issues of physical and mental/emotional health, social deviance and crime, and social and personal identity are
While dealing with the hardships of being Mexican, a woman also had to face the burden of being a female. A social hierarchy was clearly in existence. While the men were inferior to the Spaniards and Anglos because they were
This highlights that Chicanas prefer Chicanos more than they prefer each other; they perpetuate gender hierarchy by constantly placing males above females. Chicanas fear the criticism they will endure if they defy gender boundaries. Joan Riviere addresses this phenomenon in her essay “Womanliness as a Masquerade. Her essay explores the discomfort that woman feel when they act outside of the boundaries established by a male dominated society. In one example, she describes a
The Mexican culture places a high value on family. They are close-knit and united. It is common for the extended family to reside with the family in the same home. The Mexican men role is to be the support system in the household. In the Mexican culture, they are called machismo, which confirms the dominance and authority in the family. Violence is a characteristic of the machismo’s culture. They are known to be respected and seniority over the women. The women are required to tend to the house chores and take care of the children. They are expected to follow all directives given by the husbands. The husband being the head of the household is a culture norm for Mexicans. The children are to be respectable and obedient and reside with their parents regardless of the age until they are married.
Esperanza, the main character is a good example of gender roles over the course of the book. “She was a horse woman too, born like me in the Chinese year of the horse-which is supposed to be bad luck if you’re born female-but I think this is a Chinese lie because,the Chinese, like the Mexicans, don’t like their women strong.” (Cisneros 10) This is an example from the text showing how women are viewed by men in Mexican culture, they don’t like their women strong. Furthermore proving how women are viewd differently than men. Women are supposed to be the smaller, more fragile sex, compared to men who should be big, macho, and masculine. Another example from the text is “..and then as if he ust heard the news himself, crumples like a coat and cries, my brave Papa cries. I have never seen my Papa cry and don’t know what to do...I hold my Papa in my arms.” (Cisneros 56-57) This shows gender roles because Esperanza has never seen her father cry, showing that men in Mexican culture are supposed to be strong, and emointionless, unlike their female counterparts who are seen as weaker and more emotional.
In addition to Esperanza facing society's standards for women, so did many of the women on Mango Street. In this time period, countless women are stuck in gender roles. Sally says, “He never hits me hard” (Cisneros 92). Sally’s father makes her feel belittled when he abuses her because it is socially acceptable to hit your own daughter. Her father makes it seem like she is less valued than a male. Esperanza talks about Sally, “But Sally doesn’t tell about that time he hit her with his
Throughout The House on Mango Street Esperanza learns to resist the gender norms that are deeply imbedded in her community. The majority of the other female characters in the novel have internalized the male viewpoint and they believe that it is their husbands or fathers responsibility to care for them and make any crucial decisions for them. However, despite the influence of other female characters that are “immasculated”, according to Judith Fetterley, Esperanza’s experiences lead her to become a “resisting reader” in Fettereley’s terminology because she does not want to become like the women that she observes, stuck under a man’s authority. She desires to leave Mango Street and have a “home of her own” so that she will never be forced
“Beautiful and Cruel” marks the beginning of Esperanza’s “own quiet war” against machismo (Hispanic culture powered by men). She refuses to neither tame herself nor wait for a husband, and this rebellion is reflected in her leaving the “table like a man, without putting back the chair or picking up the plate (Cisneros 89).” Cisneros gives Esperanza a self-empowered voice and a desire for personal possessions, thing that she can call her own: Esperanza’s “power is her own (Cisneros 89).” Cisneros discusses two important themes: maintaining one’s own power and challenging the cultural and social expectations one is supposed to fulfill. Esperanza’s mission to create her own identity is manifest by her decision to not “lay (her) neck on the threshold waiting for the ball and chain (Cisneros 88).” Cisneros’ rough language and violent images of self-bondage reveal the contempt with which Esperanza views many of her peers whose only goal is to become a wife. To learn how to guard her power
Thesis statement: Esperanza has a variety of female role models in her life. Many are trapped in abusive relationships, waiting for others to change their lives. Some are actively trying to change things on their own. Through these women and Esperanza’s reactions to them, Cisneros’ shows not only the hardships women face, but also explores their power to overcome them.
Our families are the people we grew up around, whether they are our blood relatives or not. They are the people that make you who you are, though they might not always be around. In the story “House on Mango Street, Esperanza's family plays a huge role in shaping her identity. Throughout the story we are shown how her family, community, culture, and gender impacted her character and actions. In her community, there are Hispanic minorities and people who have lived more unfortunate lives. In fact, her family is a part of this group. Not only are people prejudiced against because of their culture, but the women face sexism from both outsiders and people in their community. Although our identities are influenced by a multitude of factors, the family we are surrounded by in our adolescence end up shaping our identities the most.