preview

Case Study On Hockey India

Good Essays

instrument to the cause of preserving the integrity of the sport, and aspiring for its orderly development. It further went on to state that the measures implemented by the consortium under its pyramid structure were not unconditionally inherent and proportionate to the achievements of purely sporting objectives. In fact, the CCI read a strong commercial dimension into the conduct of the board. While some may argue that this case lacks the balancing of rights perspective that was employed in the Hockey India judgment, it would also, perhaps, not be altogether misguided to prefer the Hockey India judgment to have progressed on the lines of the BCCI case. With a firm recommendation to revamp the core structure of its organisation such that clashes between its regulatory and organisational powers cease to be a regular feature, the CCI liberated Hockey India of the charges levelled against it. Directing the institution of a rationalised and transparent system to supervise the promulgation of NOCs, the CCI relied on an …show more content…

The stance of the CCI does appear to be rather implausible, especially as it dismisses the arguments to the alternative citing the lack of evidence that effectively corroborates that Hockey India deliberately acted against the players who wished to participate in the league. Moreover, it is pertinent to note that within a year of the alleged anti-competitive policies being drawn up by Hockey India, its proposal for a rival league was released. Hence, to absolve the body for inclusion of commercial aspects in its practices might hardly be the way to proceed. In addition, while the CoC Agreement did not explicitly enjoin the freedom of players to participate in the World Series Hockey League, it certainly served as a sheer

Get Access