preview

By Barbara Kingslover's 'Superman And Me'

Decent Essays

The essay “Superman and Me” by Sherman Alexie and “Stone Soup” by Barbara Kingslover have a multitude of differences, but similarities between the two can be revealed by understanding the overall themes of the essay. In “Superman and Me,” the underlying issue throughout is the problem of prejudice in a society. In “Stone Soup,” the problems faced are the disapproval of divorce from society. Although the essays discuss various problems in society, they both choose to defeat opposition. While “Superman and Me” discusses the difficulties of a Native American boy in a society where he is assumed to amount unsuccessfulness and “Stone Soup” discusses the overcoming of the hardships of a broken family, similarly both stories have a theme of overcoming social normalities. The essay “Stone Soup” highlights many topics related to the common “issue” of families who are binuclear. Throughout the years, divorce has become a recurring event in couple’s marriages. In the essay, Kingslover writes, “.. a culture in which serial monogamy and the consequent reshaping is families are the norm— gets diagnosed as ‘failing’.” By saying this, the author basically expresses her disapproval of our society's views of “broken” families. People too often judge what they see on the outside, and do not pay enough attention to what truly occurs in the lives of these families. Being a complete family—a father, mother, and children— is what defines normalcy to society, but how often does this work? The author of “Stone Soup” wrote, “To judge a family’s value by its tidy symmetry is to purchase a book for its cover.” To rephrase it simply, just as it is unfair to judge a book by its cover, it is evenly unfair to determine a family's successfulness by simply looking at how together or not together they present themselves. The idea of the nuclear family is not necessarily the ultimate way to achieve happiness, and throughout “Stone Soup,” the author intends on explaining that to us. A family containing step siblings, step parents, half-brothers and half-sisters, and multiple grandparents, could possibly be the happiest family, or maybe even the unhappiest, but it is not us who determines that. Nor is it the standard society has set for

Get Access