Jonathan Rowe
Essay 1: The Sun Also Rises
English 42
Doctor Speirs
3/28/2010
No Bull in Bullfighting
In The Sun Also Rises, Ernest Hemingway writes “nobody ever lives their life all the way up except bull-fighters” (100). Spoken by Jake, this line exemplifies the importance that bullfighting plays in the novel. It's not only portrayed as a sport, but rather as a complex, mathematical art in the form of a dance between the bull and fighter. The matador scene in chapter 18 is perhaps one of the richest in the novel due to it's use of symbols. The choreography between Romero and the bull is reflective not only of the characterization of Brett and Jake, but of the relationship between Brett, her masculinity, and her
…show more content…
He was once a great fighter, but now refuses to subscribe to the new “decadent” (215) bullfighting style. His fighting style represents Cohn in the sense that they both had their shining moment—Cohn's brief relationship with Brett, and Belmonte's glory days of bullfighting: which they're still trying to win back. Belmonte stands apart from the other fighters because he adheres to an traditional form of fighting. Similarly, Cohn is the only character with no involvement in the war, he preserves a sort of innocence and value system that disappeared with the “lost generation.” He tries to preserve the idea that sex equals intimacy and love, and throughout the novel his clumsy attempts to win back Brett are reflective of his refusal to understand that his brief relationship with Brett was simply a series of sexual encounters, nothing more. In conclusion, part of what makes Hemingway's style so unique is that he simply shows, without much telling. The matador scene in chapter 18 is rich because it provides penetrating insight with it's symbolism; Lady Brett with her elusive nature with men is captured through Romero's matador technique. The fact that Romero penetrates the bull with his sword accentuates the inherent masculinity that Brett displays—a sort of role reversal. Chapter 18 also highlights the character of Cohn, and his role as a foil and it's parallels to Belmonte's traditional
Whether bullfighting is considered as a sport or a form of art, its main goal is to spread happiness and entertainment among people of all ages; however, this goal can never be achieved through violence and blood. It is estimated that every year, tens of thousands of innocent bulls who never caused us any harm, get severely injured, tortured and in most cases killed, as a result of this barbaric event. The bull is a symbol of Spain and should be protected like many other animals are symbols of their counties and are sheltered such as pandas and kangaroos in China and Australia respectively. But unfortunately this majestic animal, the bull receives such a savage treatment from the country he represents. Before entering the fight, the bull is cruelly treated in such a way that cotton swabs are put into their nose to limit their respiration, Vaseline is applied into their eyes to give them a blurred vision, and their horns are usually shaved which causes them so much pain. During the fight, the defenseless and distraught bull is vulnerable to being attacked by more than one matador in the arena, and at the end of the fight the matador gives the bull the final blow by thrusting the sword into the helpless bull, followed by cutting its ears and tail and acquiring them as an award. Furthermore, this vicious event does not only harm the bull, but it also harms the matador severely and cause him several injuries, some of which might be fatal. Getting with a bull into an arena for years and years, can easily bring the matador’s life to an end sooner or later, as torturing the bull before every fight, will never be enough to guarantee the matador peaceful battle because any mistake he commits can be lethal if hit by the
Hemingway particularized the two characters, Belmonte and Romero to be in constant battle with each other. The situation became clearer when “the crowd felt it, even the people from Biarritz even the American ambassador saw it.” Pedro Romero, the young matador “did always, smoothly, calmly, and beautifully,” at dancing dangerously near the bulls. Through the comparisons of the legendary bull fighter Belmonte whose “retirement has been spoiled” to the everlasting endearing Romero, Hemingway flaunted Romero as the bull fighter who could only prove himself to be superior. The symbolical use of the bulls broadened the two fighters to encounter what their future holds as one succeeds as the other expires. Hemingway then used in epiphany, “It was
This much is clear in Mike's drunken diatribes to Cohn: "I would have thought you'd loved being a steer, Robert...They lead such a quiet life. They never say anything and there always hanging about so...Is Robert going to follow Brett around like a steer all the time?" (146) And even then, rather than knocking Mike out, which he certainly is capable of doing, Cohn takes the abuse and sulks, perhaps in the interest of preserving his interactions with Lady Brett. But Cohn is continuously bad-mouthed. The other characters make several anti-Semitic comments, scoffing his "Jewish superiority." (166) And all through this, Brett Ashley doesn't give him the time of day! How can this man be held so contemptuously by the others? Maybe because Cohn is the bull, not the steer. Hemingway hides this reference in one brief line. As Jake and Lady Brett are watching the bulls come out, Jake remarks: "Look how he knows how to use his horns...He's got a left and a right, just like a boxer." (144) The only other "boxer" in the novel is Cohn, and at one point in the book he reveals that he, too, knows how to use his horns: fed up with taking insults, he punches both Jake and Bill and knocks them out. Compare this to Jake: sexually dysfunctional, he is a steer, unable to consummate his affair with Brett Ashley. This at
““Isn’t it pretty to think so?”” (251). We are left with this one last line at the end of Ernest Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises; a line spoken in reminiscence of a reality with Brett Ashley that has always been intertwined with a dream of Brett Ashley. With the fiesta coming to its completion, we are left with Jake and his company all splitting off on their own roads, yet there lies Jake backtracking and ending up once again with Brett, this time at Hotel Montana. Jake led her off with the youthful bullfighter Pedro Romero, yet there she was putting an end to that relationship and ending right back there with Jake. It was this same song and dance that plagued Jake all throughout the story and even well before; he leads her to some other male
What is the origin of bullfighting in Spain? According to Martin Seufert's book La Corrida de Toros The Tradition of Bullfighting in Spain, there are "several" hypotheses that attempt to explain how bullfighting began in Spain. One of those hypotheses is that the tradition of the "corrida" has roots in the Middle Ages; it was a form of Roman entertainment, Seufert explains on page 4 of his book (Seufert, 2011, p. 4). It is possible that bullfighting evolved from "the sacrifice of animals in religious festivities," Seufert explains, or perhaps it was created by the Moors.
Finally, the conflict and the rising action of Hemingway’s story leads to the climax. This occurs when Wilson, Macomber, and his wife take their final journey into the wild. As a result of the sheer anger Macomber has for Wilson and his wife, his fear is drowned by adrenaline. Macomber instantly takes on the characteristics of Wilson as he takes out two buffalo on the journey. At this point, Wilson respects this
The “corrida de toros,” known in English as the bullfight, but the direct translation is running of the bulls, is a Spanish style art form. A symbol of Spanish culture that has existed for thousands of years, and for much of the time the corrida de toros has been a debate of whether it is an activity that is morally right or wrong. The origination of the bullfight and its original significance has been lost and changed over time. Marvin (1994) states the corrida de toros is “a confrontation between nature and culture which is worked out in a controlled environment in a stylized and regulated way” (p. 135).
Secondly, Hemingway portrays violence through entertainment. Hemingway demonstrates violence through entertainment by bullfighting in arenas for the crowds enjoyment or the for the matador's satisfaction, the narrator reports,”The crowd shouted all the time and threw pieces of bread down into the ring, then cushions and leather wine bottles; keeping up whisling and yelling. Finally the bull was too tired from so much bad sticking and folded his knees and lay down and one of the cuadrilla leaned out over his neck and killed him with the puntillo. The crowd came over the barrera and around the torero and two men grabbed him and held him and some one cut off his pigtail and was waving it and ran away with it” (Chapter XI). This demonstrates violence through entertainment for the reason that the crowd is very enthusiastic with the bullfight by throwing bread and alcohol finally, someone kill it takes it tail to play with, he has no remorse for the bull. Occasionally with bullfighting the matador kills the bull purely for their own satisfaction, this is shown when a man takes on many bulls and happy for himself he exclaims,”We kills the savages’ bulls, and the drunkards’ bulls, and the riau-riau dancers’ bulls. Yes. We kill them. We kill them all right. Yes. Yes. Yes” (Chapter XIII). This demonstrates violence entertainment purely for the matador by recognizing how content he is when he kills a large amount of
Reflecting members of the Lost Generation, the characters in the novel are negatively affected by being a part of it because many are incapable forming genuine relationships. The fight between Cohn, Jake, and Mike especially illustrates such an idea because it shows just how meaningless the idea of friendship is to the characters. Cohn in particular gives little meaning to true relationships. He says that Jake is his best friend, yet he insults him prior to the physical altercation; “‘You’re really about the best friend I have, Jake’” (39). Despite Jake allegedly being his best friend, he still refers to him as a pimp, showing how little Jake means to Cohn. The negative effect of meaningless, dishonest relationships is also found in the overall relationship of the group: Cohn claims to like Jake, while Jake claims to hate Cohn. Mike abhors Cohn as well, yet they are all out together nonetheless. Their lack of honesty, which led to the fight, stresses the significance of the negative effects of being a part of the Lost Generation, which is Hemingway’s meaning of the entire work.
But perhaps the greatest figure of masculinity found in Hemingway’s work is Santiago from The Old Man and the Sea. He keeps his composure and maintains dignity after the fish that he has been fighting is lost to the sharks.
Examples of the “code” hero in Hemingway’s work include Manuel the bullfighter, in “The Undefeated” he fights with a noble dignity even when he is jeered by the crowd and gored by the bull, along with Wilson, the big game hunter from “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber” who shows no fear when confronted with a charging lion. But perhaps the greatest figure of masculinity found in Hemingway’s work is Santiago from The Old Man and the Sea. He keeps his composure and maintains dignity after the fish that he has been fighting is lost to the sharks.
Bullfighting has been part of the Costa Rican culture and the Spanish tradition as many men are supporting this event. However, some questioned the danger these people are facing every time they try to kill the bull.
When answering the question “What is the “function” of the cockfight, if not to reproduce Balinese social structure?” The first thing that must be done is to first to understand what Geertz’s believed cockfight means in the Balinese culture. The next is how this does this go with “structural-functionalism”. Then lastly contrasting Geertz’s argument using the information that Evans-Pritchard gives us with his work “Nuer”. These will help with deconstructing and then answering the question.
The origins of bullfighting can be traced back to prehistoric times. The Greeks sacrificed bulls for religious reasons, but in its earliest forms, bullfighting did not even involve humans. The bull was often put into a small enclosure with another predatory animal, such as a tiger or lion, and the beasts fought to the death. The spectacle eventually evolved into a struggle between man and bull gaining similarities with what we know today as bullfighting. Along with these changes came the spectacle and formalities that are now an integral part of the corrida de toros. Arguably, the first of the modern bullfight took place in Vera, Logroño, Spain in 1133. The modern bullfight evolved from rejoneo, which
Moving on to the next character that struggles with his identity, Robert Cohn, much like Jake, wrestles with the question of is he a bull or is he a steer? While, unlike Jake, he is capable of sexual relations and has an affair with Brett, Cohn delivers the ironic statement that “it’s no life being a steer”, hinting at his insecurity in terms of his masculinity (Hemingway 145). On the surface, it would appear that Cohn does not have adequate reason to be insecure about who he is as a person. After all, he suffers no side effects from the war and is able to live his life as he pleases, dissimilar to Jake. But Cohn is set apart from the others in the story. Gross brilliantly puts into words just how subtle this differentiation can be by stating “how natural it seems . . . to call Jake Barnes Jake, Mike Campbell Mike, Bill Gorton Bill, Lady Brett Ashley Brett, and how unnatural . . . to call Robert Cohn Robert” (123). He then follows this up with the assertion that “Jake, and everyone else, calls Cohn Cohn to distance him” (Gross 123). Another aspect of this differentiation results from Cohn’s status as the only Jew in the novel. One further distinction is the idea that Cohn has never known real love. As Jake points out in the beginning, Cohn “was married by the first girl who was nice to him”, not a woman he truly loved (Hemingway 12). Upon meeting Frances, a literary woman who took a liking to Cohn and wanted to marry him, Cohn fancies that “he was sure he loved her”