preview

Brazilian Atlantic Forest

Decent Essays

Paper Review 1
“Historical climate modelling predicts patterns of current biodiversity in the Brazilian Atlantic forest” is a 2008 paper reported the results of a study using two different models, BIOCLIM and MAXENT, to display the effect of different paleoclimates, a climate of specific period time in the past, on the distribution of the tropical forest of the Atlantic region of Brazil. These predictions were used to identify refuge forest that remained relatively stable despite climate fluctuations. The authors, Ana Carolina Carnaval and Craig Moritz, then used genetic data to look for a correlation between refuge areas and genetic diversity and endemism. This study was intended to describe how the range of the Brazilian Atlantic forest changed …show more content…

While they do not come to the same conclusions that Haffer did in the Amazonian region, the authors do state that these cool, dry periods did affect the distribution of tropical vegetation and contributed to the biodiversity of the Atlantic forest and on his claim that tropical forests were quite restricted to isolated refuge areas. They point to existing pollen records that suggest an increase in both grasslands and cloud forests and a decrease in tropical forests, as well as evidence of large, stable refuge forests within the north-eastern part of Atlantic region (Q2). However they also acknowledge that other data seems show a persistence of the mesic forest, or a moderate forest with a well-balanced amount of moisture, particularly in the northern and central regions due to the more complex topography when compared the southern regions. This would discount the refugee hypothesis and imply different factors behind the high rates of …show more content…

According to their hypothesis, the predicted models of refuge forests should also predict centers of endemism, as well as high degrees of genetic diversity with the individual taxa. However, the data concerning species distribution was severely limited, meaning that they could only evaluate five taxa. The authors used the distribution of mitochondrial DNA as a representation of biodiversity within taxa. Three out of five taxa showed higher biodiversity within the modelled refuge forest: a related complex of lizards the three-toed sloth, and the brown four-eyed opossum. However, the other two, the slender-mouse opossum and the Atlantic rat, both showed higher genetic diversity in the southern region, which was not included in the predicted refuge forest and would therefore not have remained in a tropical forest. Additionally, the molecular data the sloth and lizard seems to show trends of population expansion in regions outside of the refuge forest. Furthermore, the authors refer to a recently discovered genus of lizard within one of their predicted refuges as additional evidence of the high rates of the endemic species found in the Atlantic forest (Q4). The authors present all this together as evidence of a correlation between the location of the past refuge forests they predicted

Get Access