preview

Blaine Case

Better Essays

Executive Summary:
In summary, recommendation by the banker to buy back 14 million outstanding shares of Blaine Kitchenware with $ 50 million debt and $209 million cash in hand would result in following financial metric changes: * Increase the value of the firm through the benefit of tax shield from current $960million to $1.063billion. * The offer results in 3% increase in EPS from $0.91 to $0.93 based on 2006 financial numbers. * An increase of 7.3% on ROE from 11% to 18.3% based on 2006 financial numbers. * After adjustment, share prices will be $18.0.

Proposed Buy-Back Plan Analysis:
Although Blaine’s current financial situation is sound with no debt, its current balance sheet is under levered and over liquid …show more content…

Dividends are subjected to higher tax rate compare to capital gain increased due to share buy-back. This discourages shareholders from desire to receive high dividends in place of higher capital gain as share values increase. A comparison is made below between the proposed capital structure and dividend policy. | Share buyback | One-time special cash dividends | Pros | Increase EPS/ROE, pos. sign of future earnings, Lower tax rate compare to div policy | Happy shareholders, positive sign of future earnings, | Cons | Limiting liquidity, opportunity cost | Limiting liquidity, opportunity cost, higher tax rate compare to capital gain policy | Share outstanding | Decrease | No change | EPS | Increase | No change | ROE | Increase | Increase |
In summary we recommend the share buy-back plan, as it will increase the value of the firm, shield part of income from taxes, increase return on equity and lowers agency cost. The increase in value of the firm and lower cash in hand also makes the firm less attractive target of a take-over.

Supporting Material: Case Exhibit 1 Income Statement | | | | | | With Repurchase Option | | | | | | | | | | | Operating Results: | | | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2006 | | Revenue | | | | 291,940 | 307,964 | 342,251 | 342,251 | | Less: Cost of Goods Sold | | | 204,265 | 220,234 | 249,794 | 249,794 | | Gross Profit | | | 87,676 | 87,731 | 92,458 | 92,458 | |

Get Access