preview

Black Tailed Prairie Dogs Summary

Decent Essays

This article describes the black-tailed prairie dogs (Cynomys Ludovocianus) and their coteries. Coteries are polygynous social groups that black-tailed prairie dogs live in (Hoogland 1983). In these groups, the one adult male reproduces with genetically similar females. The main purpose of this article is for the author (John L. Hoogland) to communicate and defend his earlier work on prairie dogs. These prairie dogs exist where some females and pups, within the coteries, do not breed (Hoogland 1983). Moreover, black-tailed prairie dogs behave parentally towards non-offspring (Hoogland 1983). In addition, Hoogland classifies black-tailed prairie dogs as cooperative breeders; however, they do not help breeders to the same degree as cooperative breeding birds (Hoogland 1983). …show more content…

Thus, there is no evidence shown that support Hoogland original prediction (stated in the former paragraph). Michener and Murie (1983) also argue that Hoogland’s grounded assumption is on outdated information. Hoogland refutes Michener and Murie (1983) argument by stating that the direct relationship between helper size and long-term reproductive success of females is an assumption; thus, it should not solely decide if black-tailed prairie dogs are cooperative breeders (Hoogland 1983). I find Hoogland’s last argument inadequate because he creates a prediction based off statistics that do not support black-tailed prairie dogs having an increased success from having more helpers. Although it is acceptable, it does not support his argument; and, consequently, taken advantage of by fellow researchers. The determination if black-tailed prairie dogs are cooperative breeders needs further research on the females’ long-term reproductive success. These are only a few of the examples that occur in this

Get Access