History is a collection of narratives that are created through pinpointing certain moments from the past and disregarding others. Theses narratives are what shape the way humans see the world from the past in today’s eyes. In 2014, a certain debate has sparked. The topic of this debate was which narrative is most accurate of telling the story of black people’s history in the United States. What started off with Paul Ryan, an American Politician, making his point of view on the matter public, ended with Ta-Nehisi Coates and Jonathan Chait engaging in a heated argument. Paul Ryan and Ta-Nehisi Coates both take on a position that argues for there being only one true cause of the black American, and especially urban, experience. Both leave out …show more content…
Ryan starts this argument by saying that there is strictly a cultural cause to the way black Americans live today. Arguing against this belief, Coates -- an African American writer, journalist, and educator-- believes that it is because of the institutionalized systems the black communities are living the way they are today. The only narrative that can best capture black history is one that talks about both causes. For they cannot be separated from each other. An example of a narrative like such belongs to Jonathan Chait, an American liberal commentator and writer for New York magazine. Chait’s perspective states that there is no doubt that the American black culture is what influences today’s black communities, but this culture is the result of systematic racism. The origin of the black American culture was back in the 1670s-1680s, when black slaves first started to be considered property. Racism becomes officially “put” into law for different reasons. These reasons include the high demand for tobacco production …show more content…
Black people at this time create a movement known as the “Harlem Renaissance”, and it marked the awakening of African American creative arts. Places such as the Cotton Club are established. In fact, the Cotton Club is the birthplace of Jazz, a genre of music that displays the true talent of African American Jazz musicians. Furthermore, jazz become loved by all because of the tight communities black Americans used to be forced to live in. This form of entertainment soon becomes famous throughout the whole America, black and white. Not only was music industry so greatly innovated at this time, African American poets, painters, and dancers emerged and presented their astonishing works. With these works, new ideas developed and are used today. A perfect example of one of these ideas is Hip Hop. If it were not for the “oppressive regimes of slavery and segregation” black Americans would not have solidified their “commitment to values of family, education, and self-improvement (values [are defined] as fundamentally—though not always inclusively—American)” (Sestanovich). Of course with all actions there are consequences.The sudden relocation to urban cities like Chicago caused for restrictive covenants to be placed to not allow black people to rent or buy property from white people. Not
Coates provides readers with a lesson in American history and explains to his son that race is not reality, but that “Americans believe in the reality of ‘race’ as a defined, indubitable feature of the natural world” (Coates 2015; 7) He brings the reader inside the America in which he lives. He argues that “America’s problem is not its betrayal of ‘government of the people,’ but the means by which ‘the people’ acquired their names,” meaning that America has only ever represented and supported white people, that America was founded on a system of racial bias (6). He draws attention to the struggles that peoples of color, especially black people, have faced. Those struggles generate fear, which is one of the main ideas in the
In the article “The James Brown Theory of Black Liberation”, Adolph Reed argues that the modern neoliberal interpretation and definition of black agency is both historically inaccurate and disparaging. Reed warns his audience that the reduction of historical narratives leads to detrimental politics that strays further away from democratic principles that enact positive changes. Although the illustration of self emancipation and black agency depicts history in an appealing lense, it actually minimizes the coalition of black and white people who fundamentally changed the nation.
Throughout the introduction and chapter 1 of the book, Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor explores the relations between the glorified mythology of American exceptionalism and the cultural pathology of Black livelihood, which has pinpointed and placed blame on Black people for their social and political positionality in US society. Black normativity (perceived by whiteness) is depicted as widespread poverty resulting from their innate capacities to gravitate toward impoverished material conditions. Given the dogma of white bourgeoisie ideals, the espousing of “colorblindness” has dominated mainstream academic and political discourse, which has only worked to further preclude the economic and social mobility of Black Americans. Thus, the limitations imposed upon people of color, and Black people in particular, have been the foreboding work of the current white supremacist late-stage capitalist society that continues to commodify
The history of America is one that can’t be discussed without talking about the Negro. Whether we want to admit it or not, the Negro has played an integral part in making what America what it is today. If it wasn’t for the profits generated from slavery, there would have been no way that America would have been the country that it is today. The slavery that the Negro endured has produced some positive and negatives, but it is the negatives that have been something that the Negro hasn’t been able to overcome for hundreds of years. It is these same negatives that have compelled some of the greatest black minds in history to create solutions to these problems. Minds such as Crummell, W.E.B Du Bois are some of the minds that have come up with
A free America cannot allow itself to be tainted by a schism between races. To change the inequality within America, the vanguard of the movement must be by White people. The article “Why White Women Should Read Ta-Nehesi Coates’ Book” explains why the catalyst must be White people. Author of the article Sally Kohn shows it is the responsibility of “Those…who, by virtue of our white skin, have benefitted from white supremacy and racial hierarchy are the ones who must destroy it (racism)” (Kohn et al.). Coates’s heavily discusses the idea of white guilt within his article “The Case for Reparations”. Coates’s knows that “What is needed is an airing of family secrets, a settling with old ghosts. What is needed is a healing of the American psyche and the banishment of white guilt.” (Coates, “The Case for Reparations”) This white guilt will help usher a new era of discussion and understanding of racism in America. In Coates’s memoir Between the World and Me he discusses the importance of not forgetting. Coates’s tells his son that “The forgetting is habit, is yet another necessary component of the Dream. They have forgotten the scale of theft that enriched them in slavery; the terror that allowed them, for a century, to pilfer the vote; the segregationist policy that gave them their suburbs. They have forgotten, because to remember would tumble them out of the beautiful Dream and force them to live down here with us, down here in the world.” (Coates, Between the World and Me: Notes on the First 150 Years in America) Coates’s emphasizes throughout Between the World and Me the importance of remembering. He stresses the point over and over that white people love to forget the suffering and the pain that Black Americans have gone through. Coates knows the system has managed “to obscure that racism is a visceral experience, that it dislodges brains, blocks airways, rips muscle, extracts organs, cracks bones, breaks
Thousands of white Americans came to Harlem to experience the night life. The nightclubs in New York appealed to the whites as they were very famous. Jazz music was thriving in the area. It originated in the Unites States among African-American musicians. It was at this time that jazz was at its most famous point. Many people would host rent parties which were very popular at the time. Apartment owners would hold a party and would charge a fee to those who wanted to enter. They used this money in order to pay off their rent (Worth). The influence of jazz also brought musical reviews. Soon white novelists, dramatists and composers started to exploit the musical tendencies and themes of African Americans in their works. Composers used the literary works of African-American poets in their songs. Negros began to merge with Whites into the classical world of musical composition (Wikipedia). Soon, the works of artists were being displayed in nationwide magazines. Their culture began to spread with great velocity.
Black history has been deleted from American history- discreetly but surely (Pattern #6). Those with the power and ability to include black history into the bigger scheme of reality are too disgusted or too prideful to do so, because the world doesn’t know past Martin Luther King, Rosa Parks, or cotton fields. True Black history has been excluded and left unbothered. The intellect W. E. B. Du Bois once said, “that the past is present; that without what was, nothing is” In other words, without knowing where one came from, one can never know where they are going. Solving racial issues has been attempted, without understanding the core issue underlying racism-- this is a major epidemic for America.UNCLEAR As a whole, blacks and their struggles are put on hold and Benjamin Quarels decides to speak on this harsh reality, in his text “Black History’s Diversified Clientele.” In his text, Quarels makes sure to educate his audience on those he feels should absorb and be affected by black history. These groups were black academia, white academia, black rank and file, White rank and file, and Black Revolutionary Nationalists. These groups relate two texts:CHOICE OF WORDS IS AWKWARD They came before Columbus: The African Presence in Ancient America and The Meaning of July Fourth for the Negro. Both texts can appeal to groups mentioned by Quarels. Black history is vital for people of color trying to find their true identity.
Harlem, New York became a black cultural mecca where blacks could escape the realities of the world and let their emotions run wild through music, art, literature, stage performance. The Renaissance was caused by a combination of the Great Migration during and after World War I and the social and economic boom of the “Roaring ‘20s.” Originally Harlem was meant for the upper class whites in the 1880s however, the neighborhood was rapidly overdeveloped and landlords were frantic to fill those empty buildings. So they opened the spaces up for the lower class. From 1910 to 1920 large African American populations migrated from the South to the North in attempt to be relieved of civil injustices, as they were intensified the farther south you went.
The black race has faced many hardships throughout American history. The harsh treatment is apparent through the brutal slavery era, the Civil Rights movement, or even now where sparks of racial separation emerge in urbanized areas of Baltimore, Chicago, and Detroit. Black Americans must do something to defend their right as an equal American. “I Am Not Your Negro” argues that the black race will not thrive unless society stands up against the conventional racism that still appears in modern America. “The Other Wes Moore” argues an inspiring message that proves success is a product of one’s choices instead of one’s environment or expectations.
This neighborhood lead to the flowering of African-American: culture, art, literature, and especially music. The explosion of African-American culture is known as the Harlem Renaissance. The music of the Harlem Renaissance changed African-American and American culture forever. Their music, jazz, transcended the racial divide. Jazz, created in New Orleans, traveled to Harlem, New York, marking the birth of the musical side of the Harlem Renaissance.
American history was radically changed when President Abraham Lincoln gave the very famous Emancipation Proclamation. This lead to the freedom of millions of African Americans who sought the same liberty and equality that was promised to everyone under the United States constitution. These liberties, of course, were not achieved right away. During the Reconstruction era, which is the decade right after the Civil War, many of the recently freed slaves did not have money, property, or credit. They could not buy the necessary things to enjoy their freedom, which lead to sharecropping, a glorified form of slavery. Sharecropping is a system of agriculture in which a landowner lets a tenant use the land in return for a share of the crops produced on their portion of land (Sharecropping).. Added on to this, facilities were segregated to prevent the black man from enjoying the same things as the white man due to Jim Crow laws which were enacted after the Reconstruction era. The struggle for equality and rights continued during the Gilded Age (1873-1900), the Progressive Era (1900-1920s), the Great Depression (1930s), WWII (1939-1945), the beginning of the Cold War (1947), up until the Civil Rights movement (1954-1968). At this point in history, African Americans fought for their rights and changed the course of American history. Music was a very important tool used by African Americans that helped achieve this. Ever since the slavery times, music was a big part of their culture
The last few weeks were worse than I could have ever imagined. If I had known what it this job would consist of I might not have taken it in the first place. I sailed to Africa with the crew, expecting to pick up cargo when, to my shock, it turns out we were bringing a more alive supply of 140 young African slaves. Why do people want slaves anyway? I had questioned Mr. Slater with this. “They’re better with agriculture and cattle, ” he had replied. “The Indians are no good… they’re all dead, ahahaha.” I did not have the energy to tell him why his joke was grossly unfunny. He strangely did not recognize even a slight problem with forcing people to work for us, just because they had immunities to our diseases and their government allowed it.
“The Harlem Renaissance was the development of the Harlem neighborhood in New York City as a black cultural mecca in the early 20th Century and the subsequent social and artistic explosion that resulted.” (Historycom, 2017). The movement allowed African Americans to receive exposure for their art, Moreover, it lasted for over 20 years. The African American Art provided a distinct perspective of creativity from the artists. The Harlem Renaissance was the focal point of African American Music, as a result of the movement was the birth of many Genres.
The abolishment of slavery has never made America Exceptional because the systematic oppression of African Americans occurred for decades after they were freed. American Exceptionalism is the belief that Americans are superior because the United States follows a different set of laws and norms that govern other countries. Supposedly, these differences account for the freedom that Americans have, which other countries lack. However, not all Americans, such as African Americans, have been able to practice this freedom. Even though slavery was abolished, African Americans never received the same rights as other Americans for decades. Even after receiving the same rights, African Americans were still oppressed. A country that
In “Letter to My Son,” Ta- Nehisi Coates portrays it is easy to destroy the black body through abuse and violence of one’s community to outline and create a feeling that America’s racist society created a government that oppresses and murders the black community. As an attempt to support his claim, Coates states,“—it is not so easy to get a human being to commit their body against its own elemental interest.” By explaining the difficulty someone would have to control another person, Coates is trying to