preview

Beowulf And Gilgamesh Analysis

Decent Essays

Beowulf and Gilgamesh must both fight a monster as a testament to their nobility, yet Beowulf does it for the greater good, too. Beowulf initially takes on the task of slaying Grendel due to the “[c]easeles[s] sorrow[ing] [of] the son of Healfdene” (Beowulf line 2), who is upset because Grendel “afflicted the people / [w]ith wrongs unnumbered” (Beowulf lines 4-5). Beowulf’s tribe, the Geats, has historically allied with the Danes, who are the target of Grendel’s misanthropy. Beowulf feels the need to help them out to continue this alliance. However, after Beowulf’s arrival, Hrothgar mentions that he “shall offer [Beowulf] gold for his gallant spirit” (Beowulf line 15), indicating that there is a physical reward for successfully defeating Grendel. …show more content…

In addition, Beowulf wants to fight Grendel to further prove his worth. He claims that, if he “fail[s] [his] purpose, forever [there]after / [Hrothgar] shall suffer [from] distress” (Beowulf lines 26-27). This means that Beowulf believes he is the only man that can defeat Grendel, and if he does not succeed, the Danes will be plagued by the monster for eternity. Therefore, conquering Grendel becomes more of an act of proving his alleged valiance. After successfully wounding Grendel, Beowulf “rejoice[s] in his work, / [t]he deed of renown he ha[s] done” (Beowulf lines 37-38), demonstrating his glory-driven, albeit felicitous, boasting. An important piece of Anglo-Saxon culture was boasting, and fighting Grendel allows Beowulf to exactly …show more content…

Unlike Beowulf, Gilgamesh really has no humanitarian purpose behind killing Humbaba. Humbaba “hasn’t harmed a single living being” (“Introduction” 30); the only reason he is the guardian of the Cedar Forest is because “Enlil put him there to terrify men” (Gilgamesh 93; III), not to kill men. Thus, Gilgamesh killing him would really do nothing other than anger the gods. No one will reward him for the action that seems laudable to Gilgamesh and only Gilgamesh, and no one will pass on a story of a man who slaughtered an innocent beast. With Beowulf’s killing of Grendel, however, many will honor his noble deed and courageousness. However, the butchering of Humbaba has the motivation of material reward, similar to the butchering of Grendel. Immediately after killing him, Gilgamesh and Enkidu “[bring] to earth the highest of the trees, the cedar whose top once pierced the sky” (Gilgamesh 129; V). Though it may not be gold, Gilgamesh is still able to cut down some of the world’s most prized timber. It may not have been an initial motivator of his, but it is still a promising reward for his efforts. In contrast to Beowulf, Gilgamesh knows it is not him alone who can defeat Humbaba. He needs Enkidu to “stay [...] with [him and] stand at [his] side” (Gilgamesh 119; V). This is distinctly different from Beowulf’s mindset, as Beowulf believes he is the only

Get Access