preview

Bel Canto Book Comparison

Decent Essays

If all men were supposedly created equal, shouldn’t all written literature be created equal as well? If that were true, everyone would have the hardest time trying to find quality books to read. In fact, the varying qualities from book to book are what influences people to choose what book they actually want to read. In the classic novel Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë, a young girl named Jane Eyre moves away from her cruel aunt in Gateshead to go to school and start a new life. However, the book Bel Canto by Ann Patchett portrays a setting that greatly contrasts with Jane Eyre. The story begins with the rich and powerful technology executive of Nansei named Mr. Hosokawa, who throws a birthday party that results in an invasion by several terrorists holding all the party guests hostage. Although both books have their separate key qualities, Jane Eyre should definitely be on the list for the 9th grade honors summer reading assignment next year because of its use of language, character, and theme. First, the language used in Jane Eyre is quite elaborate and intricate. This is …show more content…

On the other hand, Jane hates injustice and thinks that "If people were always kind and obedient to those who are cruel and unjust, the wicked people would have it all their own way" (75). In the book Bel Canto, the character build-up is not as significant than in Jane Eyre. For example, the accompanist of famous opera singer Roxanne Coss was significantly important to her, and "He had never told her he was a diabetic. He had chosen to stay with her rather than ask for the insulin that could save his life the poor accompanist, their friend" (82). If the accompanist was truly an important character in the story, why did he die near the beginning of the book? There was no buildup for the reader to bond with the character after he died. Character is an important attribute to plot and shapes most of the story

Get Access