preview

Being An Other By Melissa Algranati Analysis

Decent Essays

The essay “Being an Other” was written by Melissa Algranati. She is a graduate of the State University of New York at Birmingham and has a master’s degree from Colombia University. The reason as to why she wrote this particular essay was to discuss and describe her experiences of not fitting easily into any particular identity group. Her intended audience are those individuals who seem to have difficulties feeling part of a group. The text was originally published in Thomas Dublin’s “Becoming American, Becoming Ethnic: College Students Explore Their Roots.” Algranati’s identity crisis led her to publish this essay and more importantly show what it was like to be mistaken for another ethnic background. She goes on to make the noteworthy argument, …show more content…

Her mother was granted automatic U.S. citizenship as all Puerto Ricans are, however due to her social status and not knowing English many “real” Americans did not consider her a citizen. Once she perfected her English she was considered everything but a Puerto Rican. For instance, Algranati states “My mother is what people call a “white Hispanic. With her blonde hair and blue eyes my mother was taken for everything but a Puerto Rican” (146). This goes to show that most individuals will jump to conclusions before even speaking to you. Experiences that she and her family have experienced have changed the perception she has of herself. Being mistaken for various ethnicities has really made her doubt who she actually is. Algranati states “Possessing light hair and blue eyes, I am generally perceived as the “all American” girl. Occasionally I have been mistaken for Italian since my last name, Algranati, although Sephardic, has a very Italian flair to it” (147). It is because of those perceptions that others have had of her, that has led her to have personal identity issues. Due to those perceptions that people have had on her she consciously or unconsciously has felt isolated from her own ethnic groups. She now feels like she does not belong in a certain group and has difficulties relating any experiences with others. Algranati states “By being diverse I have learned that in a society that is obsessed with classification the only way I will find my place is within myself”

Get Access