preview

Behind Grandma's House

Decent Essays

“A Visit of Charity” by Eudora Welty and “Behind Grandma’s House” by Gary Soto both deal with similar topics about the relationship between the elderly and the young. “Behind Grandma’s House” is about a young child that is acting rebellious against society by cussing at an imaginary pastor, and scaring animals in the alley behind Grandmother’s house (291). He is rebellions until the grandmother comes out to hit the child in the face as discipline for what he has done (291). “A Visit of Charity” is about a young girl named Marion who visits a retirement home to visit with two elderly women so Marion can receive service hours for the Campfire Girls (116). Although “A Visit of Charity” and “Behind Grandmother’s House” both incorporate the Elderly …show more content…

In the story “Behind Grandma’s House” the young child is perceived as a misfit rebel that is trying to express himself by scaring animals and cussing at a factious pastor (291). These are two completely different characterizations of the youth. Marion is a prime example of an outgoing person that will go far in life where as the young child in “Behind Grandma’s house” is the complete opposite and would be the personality that would be getting in lots of trouble on many occasions and possibly making nothing of himself. The two stories have two completely different characterizations of the elderly. In “Behind Grandmother’s House” the grandmother is the voice of reason in the story. She hits the young child who is behaving poorly to discipline him. The grandmother knows what is right and wrong and would be considered the outgoing person in the poem much like Marion in “A Visit of Charity”. In a “Visit of Charity,” there are two elderly women one is just named the first woman and the other is the woman in bed (117). The woman in bed is a complete pessimist. She argues with the first woman about everything that comes out of her mouth including whether the two women enjoyed the last Campfire Girl that came to …show more content…

The two stories have contrasting ideas about the characterization of the elderly and the young. “A Visit of Charity” has the young optimistic and the elderly pessimistic. However, “Behind Grandma’s House” has the view of the elderly being optimistic and the young being pessimistic. The two stories also have contrasting views on the idea of philosophy ideal of the old versus the new. “Behind Grandma’s House” provides the ideal that the elderly is wiser and, therefore, are also more optimistic about life. However, “A Visit of Charity” provides the ideal of the youth being full of life and being very optimistic about life. On the other side, elderly being worn by the stresses of life so by the time you are old, you become

Get Access