preview

Atticus Finch Research Paper

Decent Essays

Krubel Ms. Hulstein Period 1 3/7/24 What makes a hero? Is Atticus Finch a hero for trying to protect Tom? The story takes place in the 1930’s and Atticus Finch is defending Tom Robinson for rape. Tom allegedly raped Mayella Ewell and was put in jail and eventually killed. “The Rise and Fall of Atticus Finch” by Metress is an article stating that Atticus is not a hero. Metress is incorrect when he says that Atticus is not a hero because Atticus protected Tom, damaged his reputation, and taught his children not to be racist. Firstly, Metress is incorrect when he states that Atticus is noblesse obliged because Atticus protects Tom outside the courthouse. Freedman claims that Atticus is noblesse obliged to help Tom. The text reads, “He does so …show more content…

That is incorrect because Atticus protected Tom outside the jailhouse. The text reads, “In the light from its bare bulb, Atticus was sitting propped against the front doors.” (Lee 171). Atticus was sitting outside the jailhouse to stop a mob from lynching Tom. He knew that he could get hurt, but he still went anyway. Atticus did not accept because he was noblesse obliged, but because he cared. He waited outside the courthouse and could have been killed as well for protecting Tom. If he was noblesse obliged, he would have just let the mob kill Tom because all he had to do was defend him in court. Secondly, Metress claims that Atticus is doing it for himself, which is incorrect because he is damaging his family's name. Atkinson says that Atticus is doing it for himself and does not mention Tom. The text reads, “He makes clear several times that it is his own sense of personal rectitude and his need to be seen as virtuous by others that compel him to take Tom’s case.” (Metress Part 8). Atticus is only taking the case because he wants to be seen as virtuous and does not care about the case because it makes him look …show more content…

The text reads, “‘He’s ruinin’ the family, that's what he’s doin’.’” (Lee 94). Francis is saying that Atticus is ruining the family for taking Tom’s case and calling him a black people lover. Metress says that Atticus took the case because he wanted to be seen as virtuous, but taking the case damaged his reputation. Even his family says that he is ruining their reputation. Lastly, Metress says that Atticus tolerated the racism, which is incorrect because he teaches his kids not to be racist. Freedman says Atticus tolerates all the racism. The text reads, “‘Atticus Finch knows about the grinding, ever-present humiliation and degradation of the black people of Maycomb; he tolerates it; and sometimes he even trivializes and condones it.’” (Metress Part 5). Atticus tolerates all the racism and does not care about it. He condones it and acts like nothing is wrong. Even with all his power, he does not try to make any change to the racism in Maycomb. Yet again, Metress is incorrect because Atticus teaches his kids not to be racist. The text reads, “‘Do you defend [black people], Atticus?’ I asked him that

Get Access