preview

At Will Employment Case Study

Decent Essays

The Ethics of At-Will Employment Those in favor of the at-will employment doctrine point out that it is only fair that if an employee can quit at any time, giving the employer the same freedom is only fair. While this may sound fair and logical, the reality is, different I believe it just gives an employer the ability to discriminate against employees. In 2012, New York’s court of appeals upheld the employment at-will case Sullivan v. Harnish. Chief Judge Lippman issued a dissent, expressing strong concern that giving employers the right to fire compliance officers for doing their job could lead to more financial scandals like the Madoff Ponzi scheme (Hamid, 2014). At-Will Employment Doctrine The at-will employment doctrine is the belief that employers have the right to fire anyone at any time for any reason, …show more content…

This is the case with most union employees, the union enters into a collective bargaining agreement that helps protect members from termination without cause. Public Sector Traditionally public sector employees have not been subject to at-will employment. Laws and regulations enacted to try to insulate public employees from political whim. At one time, it was commonplace to see public employees fired to make room for a newly elected politician’s supporter. Civil Service commissions were set up to control the political nature of public jobs, these laws made it hard to fire a public employee without cause. The state of Georgia in 1996 started to embrace at-will employment for public employees (Jordan, 2014). The rational for this was to make public entities more efficient, by allowing the dismissal of poor performing employees. They also believed that existing employees would be more motivated, knowing they could be fired for poor performance. This deregulation has severely limited due process rights for employees (Jordan,

Get Access