preview

Argumentative Analysis

Decent Essays

Many philosophers favor rural walking over urban because the release of constraints allows for more open thinking. One critic, Solnit, defined these constraints as the built walkways and buildings of a city.
When cities first started out they were just a collection of people residing together for mutual benefit. The closer they lived, the better they could share resources, this has since expanded exponentially. Cities today symbolize mass united expanses of businesses and houses consisting of everything a family may need. The safety of Nature has been replicated through conventions. As an example streetlights exist to prevent accidents, driving lanes to increase efficiency, along with crosswalks and sidewalks to allow for walking. With the …show more content…

“To see everything from the height of his years. The outlook born of experience” (Gros 160). Experiences teach the wise that no benefit presents itself in defying the law, but children haven’t had the experiences to qualify this and so naturally they push the limits. The execution of laws center themselves around public safety. By focusing on safety, critics overlook the deeper problem of sacrificing the right of free choice. Thoreau reminds readers of this problem when he writes “There is something servile in the habit of seeking after a law which we may obey. We may study the laws of matter at and for our convenience, but a successful life knows no law. It is an unfortunate discovery certainly, that of a law which binds us where we did not know before that we were bound. Live free, child of the mist” (Thoreau 37). In other words, we seek out laws to ensure we stay out of trouble. Nobody wants the hassle of dealing with consequences but on the other hand we want the responsibility to decide; the middle ground then becomes convenience. Laws exist for a reason but extremists believe if the laws were always followed without arguments then laws would never have progressed to what they embody today. Thoreau calls humans to not be servile; instead liberation needs to occur, humans needs to be free to make choices on what they deem best for themselves, just as animals

Get Access