preview

Benito Cerreno Sparknotes

Good Essays

Analysis of Critical Essays on Benito Cereno



It is possible to divide the critics into two camps regarding Herman Melville's purpose in writing "Benito Cereno." Joseph Schiffman, Joyce Adler, and Sidney Kaplan all argue that Melville wrote the story to make a comment on slavery. On the other hand, Sandra Zagarell and Allan Emery contend that Melville goes beyond slavery and is pointing out other flaws in mid Nineteenth century American notion.



"Benito Cereno" tells the story of a slave revolt on a ship at sea. Schiffman, Adler, and Kaplan argue that Melville wrote the story as a comment on slavery. Schiffman and Adler contend that Melville's novella is a clear indictment of slavery. Kaplan takes the …show more content…

He argues that Melville wrote a moral tale, not an abolitionist story. At the end of the essay, Schiffman contradicts himself by proclaiming that Babo's head being "unabashed" as Benito Cereno, the slave trader, "follow[s] his leader" is an indictment of slavery.





"'Benito Cereno': Slavery and Violence in the Americas" is Joyce Adler's analysis of

Melville's story. While agreeing with Schiffman that Melville wrote an anti-slavery book, she

goes beyond her predecessor by claiming that Melville intended to show intricacies of the

master/slave relationship and the violence that slavery breeds. Adler argues that the master

and slave are "inseparable, irreconcilable, and interchangeable" (82). She points out that Babo

frees himself and subsequently enslaves his former master, Don Benito. She says that

Delano's statement, "Ah, this slavery breeds ugly passions in man," is Melville's indictment

of the practice (86). Adler does not accept Schiffman's color analysis. She contends that black

and white are merely opposites and have no significance other than their relative positions in

the master/slave relationship. She also places the story in a much broader historical context.

She concludes that "Benito Cereno" is Melville's attempt to warn the United States of its

critical flaw: slavery. To this end, Adler includes exhaustive evidence that Melville linked

Spain and the United States in the characters of

Get Access