preview

Analysis Of 'A Fireman's Story' By Hanson Baldwin

Decent Essays

History can be presented in many different ways. In the two eyewitness accounts by Harry Senior and Mrs. D. H. Bishop and the article by Hanson Baldwin, they tell different stories about what happened on the Titanic. The ship was supposedly “unsinkable.” The authors’ perspectives affect the details that they include in their accounts of the sinking of the Titanic. In the eyewitness account called “A Fireman’s Story” by Harry Senior. The author describes his experience on the “unsinkable” Titanic. Harry Senior was a fireman o the Titanic. He wasn’t able to get on the lifeboat because he was a male fireman. Firemen on the ship weren’t considered to be as important as others. The author provides subjective details. He experienced the sinking first hand. Being a male fireman, you would expect him to show bravery, which he did. For example, in his account, he states, “I saw an Italian woman holding two babies. I took one of them and made the woman jump overboard with the baby, while I did the same with the other.” By doing that, it shows bravery. Many people wouldn’t dream of doing that. This quote enhances the reader’s understanding by making them realize not many people were fortunate enough to get on a lifeboat right away. In comparison, in the eyewitness …show more content…

Titanic,”by Hanson W. Baldwin, the author explains the events from the Titanic. Baldwin was one of America’s great journalists. The author provides objective details. He gives details about the Titanic. Even though he didn’t experience it personally, his details make you think otherwise. To illustrate, in his account, he states, “The White Star liner Titanic, largest ship the world had ever known, sailed to Southampton on her main voyage to New York on April; 10, 1912.” He would include this to give details about the ship; something a journalist would do. The quote adds enough, but not too much, information to keep the reader wanting to read

Get Access