preview

AT & T Case Summary

Decent Essays

Legal Brief Assignment
Citation
FCC v. AT&T Inc. 562 U.S. 397 (2011) United States Court for Appeal of the Third Circuit.
The area of communication law this case applies to is the right to privacy. The right to privacy as we discussed in class can be found in chapter six of our textbook.
Facts of the Case
CompTel a small subgroup part of AT&T distributor and competitor, filed a FOIA request with the Federal Communications Commission in 2005, the notion was to find documents related to the federal communication commission question, which was querying whether AT&T had cheated CompTel, by having overpriced goods in their work on a technological education project. AT&T denied having being involved with such matter and the FCC is refusing to release the documents. Their reasoning is that the production of the documents violated Exemption 7c of the FOIA, a law passed by congress. The main law was to exempt the disclosure of records that would result into an invasion of “personal privacy” of the new document holders. The Federal communications commission rejected AT&T's argument that stated that they receive the documents. However, in September of the year …show more content…

As cooperation are not naturally born people does the term personal privacy hold?

The Decision of The Court
REVERSED: The decision of the court was read by Roberts, C. J. the opinions of the justices except “Kagan who took no part in the consideration or decision of the case is as follow”: the court held that per exception C of the FOIA, large cooperation such as AT&T cannot us the phrase personal privacy for the sake of their entity. The phrase can only be argued for a person that is naturally born. As documents were already released to the FCC, their right to privacy cannot be guaranteed.

Get Access