preview

A White Heron Character Analysis

Decent Essays

The protagonists of each stories “ Hills Like White Elephants” and “A White Heron” have conflicts with another male character, whom they have a romantic relationship with one another. The male characters, the American and a young ornithologist hunter, share a similar ambition of getting what they want. The American wants his female love interest to have an operation, claiming that it is the best option for their relationship. As for the young ornithologist hunter, he has a desire to catch a rare bird, but is having difficulties locating it. Although these strong leading female protagonists, Jig and Sylvia, are in certain situations where they do not have a solid agreement with the other male characters. The story progresses for both protagonists, …show more content…

According to the text, the operation is referring to an abortion of some sort, but it is not specified what it is. He seemed to be very knowledgeable as he is able to be convincing Jig when reasoning why the operation must be done. The American was biased with his own personal preference of having the operation without Jig’s opinion. In addition, he consciously made her feel bad as it states in the text, “If you don’t want to you don’t have to. I wouldn’t have you do it if you didn’t want to” (Hemingway 230). Primarily trying to make her feel bad for her ‘wrongful’ decision to him. The American’s tone made Jig feel guilty and made her rethink her decisions. Jig was indecisive about having the operation or not as she and the American discussed it in the story. As they argue, Jig seems to be less convincing and firm about her statement of not doing the operation. The American’s tone may have been persuasive as he was preparing them for their future, but at the same time he was selfish as he did not acknowledge anything she said, “But I don’t want you to, I don’t care anything about it” (Hemingway 231). Towards the end, she already knew that from the start of the argument, their ‘love’ would no longer be the same as it was before or after the decision with the operation, as it was stated in the text “And if I do it you’ll be happy and things will be like they were and …show more content…

As Sylvia wanders around the city, she meets a young ornithologist. The ornithologist merely asks Sylvia for help to search for a rare bird. The ornithologist’s tone may sound as if he was desperate for this creature, “I would give ten dollars to anybody who could show it to me” (Jewett 61). She soon discovers that they both share a common interest for animals and nature. At this moment, Sylvia found the ornithologist charming and wants to build a friendship with this character. As the story progresses, Sylvia realizes that the ornithologist is a hunter and changes her interest in him, as it states in the text, “Sylvia would have liked him vastly better without the his gun” (Jewett 61). In this situation, Sylvia rethinks to herself on making her decision, according to the text, “Wondering over and over again what the stranger would say to her, and what he would think when she told him how to find his way straight to the heron’s nest” (Jewett 64). Whether she should go against what she believes in to protect a rare bird and receive ten dollars, to help support her family or ruin a relationship with the hunter. In the end, Sylvia stays true to what she believes in and did not reveal the bird’s location. By choosing this decision she has risked her new relationship with the

Get Access