preview

A River Runs Trough It: Film Analysis

Satisfactory Essays

Jonathan Bobadilla Mrs. Maxson English 1A October 7, 2014 A River Runs Trough It There are many comparisons between A River Runs Trough It by Norman Maclean and The Film " A River Runs through It" by Robert Redford. Norman Maclean focused on the relationship between Nature, Faith and Art. Robert Redford focused on two brothers specially on Paul. Missoula Montana was the place that this novella took place, in both the film and the book. The Blackfoot river played a significant role in the lives of Norman and Paul Maclean. The river was their own special and unique place where they would relax and enjoy nature. Fly fishing was more than a hobby and competing against each other was something very common. Maclean Focused on the relationship between …show more content…

Maclean's main message was to give his audience and to let them feel the love of brotherhood. Maclean did a good job on describing every detail of fishing. This made the audience who doesn't know anything about fishing to have a better understanding about fly fishing. Which made it boring for me. On the other hand Redford did the exact same thing, but since it was visual it made it more interesting and convincing. The river was more than just fly fishing. The river and fly fishing kept the bond between Norman and Paul. Which Redford didn't really focused on the river, he focused more on Paul's behaviors. Redford focused more on Paul to make his death more dramatic and unforgettable. The audience usually forgets when someone survives, they will often say that it was a good movie with a happy ending, but when the main character of a film dies, it makes it unforgettable to the audience. They will talk about his death and how good or bad he was. Maclean was the one who decided that Paul was going to die, but Redford gave more drama and suspense to his death. Paul and Norman loved

Get Access