Critical Theory
#1
The critical theory arose from the Frankfurt School, the collective works of German theorists. Critical theory’s roots are centered on the works of The Institute for Social Research and those researchers who promoted Karl Marx theory of idealism. Intellectuals at the school developed kritisch Therorie, the critical theory of society, which was created to directly interpret Marxism. These theorists wanted to revise Marx’s theory that capitalism and the concept that the best way to change the structure of society and politics was a revolution.
Critical theory and materialism are closely linked, the two elements that link these two ideas are; 1. The concern with human happiness, and 2. The belief that happiness can be granted by a transformation of the material conditions of existence. Marcuse’s version of critical theory was greatly influenced from the works of Hegel and Marx. He combined their thoughts, concluding that history is the ground in which humans seek the freedom to establish universal rationality.
Technological rationality, an extension of Weber’s work conducted by Marcuse, argued that modern industrial society was dominated by a technological rationality with the working middle class as societies defenders and supporters. A concern was the cost of material satisfaction was causing society to lose their individual liberties and freedom. This rational makes two claims, the workers of an industrial society suffer from false consciousness and
Critical Theory: Social and economic oppression of a group of individuals who eventually recognize their oppression and strive change in order to eliminate the oppression.
Critical theory is an idea that speaks to the individual desire for achieving success as defined by the individual and not the society. It lends itself more to finding out why there are paradoxes in society.
The first step is to separate what one believes from that one knows, and to separate what is from what must be. (Hinchey, 5) By doing this, one is able to begin to deconstruct the assumptions about the system in which we operate, which allows the individual to see the system as custom instead of irrefutable law. The next step in critical theory is
In the education world, the topic of critical pedagogy will be introduced to many. Before one can discuss critical pedagogy, one must know the meaning of it. Critical pedagogy is known to many as the study of oppression in education. It includes how issues of sex, race, gender, culture, and other social factors shape education. Critical pedagogy is also known by many as how teaching and learning takes place. An example of critical pedagogy is when students are able to ask why and respond or challenge questions that are asked in a free manner. When thinking of critical pedagogy, one must think of going beyond the first level of the meaning of a word, topic, or issue.
Cleaning up down South: supermarkets, ethical trade and African horticulture is a piece by Susanne Freidberg published in Social and Cultural Geography journal in 2003 (Freidberg, 2003). Susanne Friedberg holds PhD from UC Berkely and is a Professor of Geography in Darmouth College, New Hampshire (“Susanne Freidberg,” n.d.). In the article the author argues that the ethical standards have become fetishised. The UK supermarkets compliance with such standards edges on paranoia. It does not mean that the supermarkets care about these standards from moral point of view but that the compliance is driven by fear of bad
Critical theory is divided into three sub-theories: Max Horkheimer’s emancipatory normative and critical thinking playing a role in the formation of democracy; Herbert Marcuse’s metaphilosophy and use of reasoning. The central aim of Horkheimer’s critical theory was the formation of a democratic state where the society constitutes of rational individuals with conscious control over the matters of both public and private life. He asserted in the Traditional and Critical theory (Ingram), individuals should become producers of their social life in totality. This is the path set up for others to follow to question the anti-democratic trend in then fascist society. Hence, Critical theory took on different turn focusing on the close bond between the state and the market in capitalism. This is an expansion of Marxian criticism of the
Karl Marx is the first in a series of 19th and 20th century theorists who started the call for an empirical approach to social science. Theorizing about the rise of modernity accompanied by the decline in traditional societies and advocating for a change in the means of production in order to enable social justice. Marx’s theories on modernity reveals his beliefs of modern society as being influenced by the advancement of productive forces of modern industry and the relationships of production between the capitalist and the wage laborers. The concept of modernity refers to a post-feudal historical period that is characterized by the move away from feudalism and toward capitalism. Modernity focuses on the affects that the rise of capitalism has had on social relations, and notes Karl Marx and Max Weber as influential theorists commenting on this. The quick advancement of major innovations after the Enlightenment period known as modernity stood in stark contrast to the incremental development of even the most complex pre-modern societies, which saw productive forces developing at a much slower pace, over hundreds or thousands of years as compared to modern times, with swift growth and change. This alarming contrast fascinated Marx who traced the spawning of modern capitalism in the Communist Manifesto, citing this record speed as the heat which generated the creation of the global division of labor and a greater variety of productive forces than anytime before. Ultimately,
John Schmidt is an employee who injured his hand doing the movement of a piece of wood through a table saw while in the production shop. John claims that the company is to bless because the machine was not safe for use. His manager, foreman and the Safety Department are all involved in the investigation. A Critical Analysis in process to determine who was at fault and what measures could have prevented issue occurrence and the precautions which can be implemented to prevent a reoccurrence.
Critical theory in social work validates people’s experiences of oppression in a capitalist society (Payne, 1997). It understands that social problems that arise from capitalism, such as high suicide rate in South Korea are not due to individuals’ failings. In contrast to social work practice theories which are oriented around the individual, critical theory’s focus is on the social circumstances (Payne, 1997). It criticise theories such as psychodynamic and CBT for diverting attention from inequality and social injustices. Social work response to depression based on critical theory would be to transform or change the society and alleviate conditions of social structures that cause depression, rather than deal with the effects and help people
With regards to the validity of the resurrection of Jesus Christ, a person who believes in the religious position of fideism would base their entire argument on a passage of the Bible. For instance, they might quote, “‘For my thoughts are higher than your thoughts, neither are your ways My ways,’ declares the Lord. ‘For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and My thoughts than your thoughts.’”1 In turn, they would reach an interpretation of these verses which presents the Lord as a possessor of vastly more knowledge than mankind. This is why His thoughts and methods are above our discernment because we cannot always understand them. The strength of this philosophical ideology is that it places the
The critical theory came from a study by a group of sociologists at the University of Frankfort in Germany who were also know as the Frankfurt school. The Frankfurt school is known for its scholars that are always after developing the critical theory and popularizing the dialectical method of learning by questioning and interrogating the society’s contradictions, and is mostly associated with the work of max Horkheimer. The school or institute was founded by Marxist scholar carl Grunberg in 1923, and initially financed by another Marxist scholar, Felix Weil. Critical theory as it is known today can be traced to Marx's critique of
Along with this, theorists came to determine [or hypothesize] what the next years will be or what will become from the seemingly imperfect world. Karl Marx, Max Weber, Emile Durkheim, and Georg Simmel, although having differences in opinion, based on different times and ‘awareness’, focused on concern for the human condition. As discussed below, these theorists also have some very distinctive similarities and will be explained in detail. In particular, their ideas amount to what can be classified as a ‘diagnosis’ of modernity: what is happening; why it is happening; where will it take humanity; and in some cases where society should go.
Critical realism has been formed out of frustration with positivism and constructivism and the associated limitations of the two concepts. Founded by Bhaskar through a
The notion of ‘critical’ is primarily associated with the critical theory of the Frankfurt School where social theory should be oriented towards critiquing and changing society.
Critical Theory as a method of inquiry is widely used when questioning power structures. The concern with changing a system, may it be economic, social or political. Higgs and Smith (2015:67). According to Higgs and Smith (2015:67), critical theory originates in the 1930’s through German philosophy. The first people to get involved were mostly concerned with the problems of Nazism. Critical theory, from the start, was not just concerned with trying to resist the Nazis, critical theory believes that all power structures are dangerous and destructive. Critical theory believes that power structures not only drive our economic and social life but