Policy Identification Worksheet Updated Summer 2022-1 (4) (1)
docx
School
Pasco-Hernando State College *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
2380
Subject
Political Science
Date
Apr 3, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
5
Uploaded by UltraLarkMaster1082
Policy Identification Worksheet
Policy topic: Immigration
Directions: Do some research and find 3 existing or proposed recent U.S. policies (laws, statutes, etc.) published or proposed on this topic. Do not
describe policies proposed/implemented prior to 2000. In addition to a brief description of the policy, you will also indicate the stance (for or against), level of implementation, and provide a link to the actual policy.
Policy 1
Policy name (Precise bill/policy/legislation name): Immigration Parole Reform Act of 2023 Policy link (Include a direct link to the policy. Do not use Wikipedia, news articles, etc. Go directly to the source for information): https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-
congress/senate-bill/505?s=1&r=96
Implementation level (Circle one of the following that fits your policy): Organizational/Institutional
Local
State
Federal Brief summary of the policy in your own words (minimum 100 words):
The Immigration Parole Reform Act of 2023 was passed in Senate and sponsored be Senator Chuck Grassley. This bill allows the Attorney General to restrict aliens from coming into the United States for reasons deemed necessary in order to protect public interest. This also limits the power of the Department of Homeland Security. This bill can restrict what counts as an “urgent humanitarian reason,” that would allow them to be granted parole. It also rejects those on parole from being labeled as a class of individuals. Certain individuals such as family members to active-duty armed force memebers and those of cuban nationality can be granted parole under the authotiyy of the Department of Homeland Security.
On a scale of 1 to 5, where do you feel this policy lands on the spectrum of being on the
Pro or Con side of your topic? Highlight the appropriate number.
Pro side (in favor of)
Con side (against)
1
2
3
4
5
Briefly explain why you think your policy falls on that number in the spectrum. Why is this policy pro, con, or neutral? Do parts of the policy take components from both sides of the topic? For example, does it represent a solution that individuals on different sides of the topic might agree upon? Or, does the policy mainly support one perspective? (minimum 100 words): I believe this policy falls under 4, leaning towards the con side. This is due to the limitations that this bill exhibits for individuals when determining whether their situation is an urgent humanitarian reason to grant parole. I believe those on the other side of the spectrum will not agree with this due to even when you are granted parole, you are not permitted to work while in the United States. This limits them from being able to provide for themselves and potentially for their loved ones. Also
the exceptions such as those with Cuban nationality and if they are a family member of active duty armed forces opens up windows for those who would have otherwise been rejected by this Reform act, Policy 2
Policy name (Precise bill/policy/legislation name): The Dignity Act of 2023
Policy link (Include a direct link to the policy. Do not use Wikipedia, news articles, etc. Go directly to the source for information): https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-
congress/senate-bill/1208?s=1&r=97#:~:text=Introduced%20in%20Senate
%20(04%2F19%2F2023)&text=This%20bill%20directs%20the
%20Department,purposes%2C%20and%20addresses%20related%20issues.
_____
Implementation level (Circle one of the following that fits your policy): Organizational/Institutional
Local
State
Federal Brief summary of the policy in your own words (minimum 100 words):
The Dignity Act of 2023 was introduced to the Senate on 5/23/2023. The reason for this bill is to help individuals become hired through U.S. Customs and Border
Protection and also removes defers for aliens who are eligible. It also provides funding for Border security, such as through improving outdated infrastructure and equipment. And establishes operational control, preventing the unlawful entry into the United States. Pathways to citizenship are established through programs that this bill supports such as: Dreamers, Keeping Families together and the Redemption program.
On a scale of 1 to 5, where do you feel this policy lands on the spectrum of being on the
Pro or Con side of your topic? Highlight the appropriate number.
Pro side (in favor of)
Con side (against)
1
2
3
4
5
Briefly explain why you think your policy falls on that number in the spectrum. Why is this policy pro, con, or neutral? Do parts of the policy take components from both sides of the topic? For example, does it represent a solution that individuals on different sides of the topic might agree upon? Or, does the policy mainly support one perspective? (minimum 100 words):
I put a 1 for this bill, on the side of Pro (in favor of.) This bill creates multiple opportunities for immigration, through providing a path to permanent residency to eligible individuals, who are referred to as the Dreamers. It also establishes a dignity program, which adjourns the removal of those who are eligible without lawful immigration status. Lastly, the Redemption program, provides a way for permanent residency for those in the dignity program, and having the ability to make additional payments into the United States worker fund.
Policy 3
Policy name (Precise bill/policy/legislation name): American Dream and Promise Act of 2023
Policy link (Include a direct link to the policy. Do not use Wikipedia, news articles, etc. Go directly to the source for information): https://immigrationforum.org/article/american-
dream-and-promise-act-of-2023-bill-summary/?
gad_source=1&gclid=CjwKCAiAloavBhBOEiwAbtAJO4_MPXSN0UNBW9aLU_w8Sem8
o86Yfaf9I4jAYWOqI1TOpkxkp76EoRoCeqUQAvD_BwE
_____
Implementation level (Circle one of the following that fits your policy): Organizational/Institutional
Local
State
Federal
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Brief summary of the policy in your own words (minimum 100 words): The American Dream and Promise Act of 2023 is a bill introduced by Silvia Garcia. This bill would allow 2 million Dreamers who entered the United States as children to be able to legally obtain non-permeant citizenship in the United States. This citizenship would be valid for ten years, protecting them from deportation. It also allows those to be able to obtain green-cards if they meet requirements such as: Establishing they have lived in the US for three years before the bills enactment. It would protect TPS holders from countries such as El Salvador, Haiti, Honduras, Nepal, Nicaragua, Somalia, South Sudan, Syria and Yemen.
On a scale of 1 to 5, where do you feel this policy lands on the spectrum of being on the
Pro or Con side of your topic? Highlight the appropriate number.
Pro side (in favor of)
Con side (against)
1
2
3
4
5
Briefly explain why you think your policy falls on that number in the spectrum. Why is this policy pro, con, or neutral? Do parts of the policy take components from both sides of the topic? For example, does it represent a solution that individuals on different sides of the topic might agree upon? Or, does the policy mainly support one perspective? (minimum 100 words):
I put this on 1, the pro side. This is due to the fact that this bill creates many opportunities for immigrants, specifically the Dreamers and those who are TPS holders to be able to have the oppurtunity to obtain protection and an unability to be deportated. I believe those who are on the Con side would agree that for cases such as the Dreamers, who have special circumstances, this allows the to control who is able to enter and have the ability to work and even be able to get a green-
card. This helps distinguish between the eligible aliens and those who are not admissable such as thse with criminal backgrounds and offenses.
Topic Stakeholders
Stakeholders are people or organizations that have an interest or concern in something (a.k.a. have a stake in the outcome). Now that you are familiar with policies on this topic, you should also become familiar with organizations/agencies that are interested in
this issue and have a position statement that may support or oppose legislation on this particular topic. Below you will identify organizations/agencies which are stakeholders for this topic. Include the name of the organization, paraphrase their position statement on the topic, and include a link to the statement you are paraphrasing. The first one, the American Public Health Association (APHA), has already been selected for you and you will fill out
the rest. Researching APHA’s position on this topic will help you understand the public health perspective on this topic. 1.
Organization Name: American Public Health Association (do not remove)
Position Summary (1 sentence): APHA believes public health should be protected for immigrants and immigrant communities. __________________
______
Link to Position Statement:https://www.apha.org/topics-and-issues/immigrant-health
_______
2.
Position statement from an organization with a “con”
stance:
Organization Name: _Federation for American immigration reform____________________________________________________
Position Summary (1 sentence): FAIR suggests that irresponsible border policies can undermine our own nations ability to be a successful change agent for the human race.
____________________________
Link to “Con” Position Statement: https://www.fairus.org/?
gclid=CjwKCAiAloavBhBOEiwAbtAJOxuR1Jod6WY6H95sMyLSRzMEfIfPSC6L9n8B
pVrPR8buwg-gsXaw9xoC3hsQAvD_BwE _______
3.
Position statement from an organization with a “pro”
stance:
Organization Name: _____The opportunity agenda________________________________________________
Position Summary (1 sentence): TOA is an organization dedicated to building cultural power to move the United States toward a vision of justice, equity and opportunity for all.
____________________________
Link to “Pro” Position Statement: https://opportunityagenda.org/about-us/ _______