The paper “The Psychological Consequences of Money” (Science [2006]: 1154–1156) describes several experiments designed to investigate the way in which money can change behavior. In one experiment, participants completed one of two versions of a task in which they were given lists of five words and were asked to rearrange four of the words to create a sensible phrase. For one group, half of the 30 unscrambled phrases related to money, whereas the other half were phrases that were unrelated to money. For the second group (the control group), none of the 30 unscrambled phrases related to money. Participants were 44 students at Florida State University.
Participants received course credit and $2 for their participation. The following description of the experiment is from the paper:
Participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions, in which they descrambled phrases that primed money or neutral concepts. Then participants completed some filler questionnaires, after which the experimenter told them that the experiment was finished and gave them a false debriefing. This step was done so that participants would not connect the donation opportunity to the experiment. As the experimenter exited the room, she mentioned that the lab was taking donations for the University Student Fund and that there was a box by the door if the participant wished to donate. Amount of money donated was the measure of helping. We found that participants primed with money donated significantly less money to the student fund than participants not primed with money [t(38) = 2.13, P< 0.05].
The paper also gave the following information on amount donated for the two experimental groups.
- a. Explain why the random assignment of participants to experimental groups is important in this experiment.
- b. Use the given information to verify the values of the test statistic and degrees of freedom (38, given in parentheses just after the t in the quote from the paper) and the statement about the P-value. Assume that both
sample sizes are 22. - c. Do you think that use of the two-sample t test was appropriate in this situation? Hint: Are the assumptions required for the two-sample t test reasonable?
Want to see the full answer?
Check out a sample textbook solutionChapter 11 Solutions
Introduction To Statistics And Data Analysis
- Craik & Tulving ran an experiment to determine how depth of processing during study affects memory. In the study phase, 12 participants made judgments about words. In one block of trials (the visual condition) they indicated whether the words were written in upper case or lower case; in another block of trials (the auditory condition) they indicated whether the words contained an "ee" sound; in another block of trials (the meaning condition) they indicated whether the meaning of the words was pleasant or unpleasant. There were 12 words in each block. After completing the study phase, participants were asked to write down all the words they could remember. Here are the data: Mean Visual 3.5 Auditory 4.5 Meaning 6.0 Standard Deviation 1.5 1.6 1.9 Compared to the within-subjects design, the between-subjects design (select all that apply) Oa. Would have less statistical power O b. Would be less prone to experimenter bias O c. Would be less prone to order effects Od. Would have better…arrow_forwardCommute Times: According to the New York Times Almanac, a survey of 15 large U.S. cities found that the average commute time one way to work was 25.4 minutes. A chamber of commerce executive feels that the one way to work commute in her city is less than this and wants to publicize this. In order to assess her belief, she randomly selected 25 commuters in her city and found the average one way commute time to work to be 22.1 minutes with a standard deviation of 5.3 minutes. At a 1% significance level assess the validity of the claim she would like to advertise for her city. a. What decision was made with regard to the null hypothesis? b. What is your conclusion based on the available data? c. What is your best point estimate of the average one-way commute time to work in this city? d. Provide a 99% confidence interval for the average one-way commute time to work in this city.arrow_forwardCommute Times: According to the New York Times Almanac, a survey of 15 large U.S. cities found that the average commute time one way to work was 25.4 minutes. A chamber of commerce executive feels that the one way to work commute in her city is less than this and wants to publicize this. In order to assess her belief, she randomly selected 25 commuters in her city and found the average one way commute time to work to be 22.1 minutes with a standard deviation of 5.3 minutes. At a 1% significance level assess the validity of the claim she would like to advertise for her city. a. What is the inherent question of interest here? b. What might be a reasonable description of the population of interest? c. What is the relevant sample here? d. What is the random variable being evaluated here? e. What is the population parameter of interest? f. What is this…arrow_forward
- A researcher is interested in whether completing a six-week speed-reading course designed for sighted readers affects reading speed among blind Braille readers. She has blind adults complete a reading speed test before and after a six-week speed-reading course. The researcher randomly selects a sample of 50 blind Braille readers who, at the beginning of the study, scored an average of 261 words per minute on the reading speed test. After the speed-reading course, the blind Braille readers scored an average of 7 words per minute higher. The standard deviation of the difference scores was 21. Since the sample size is larger than 30, the researcher can assume that the sampling distribution of MD is normal. She uses a repeated-measures t test to test that the mean difference is zero, and she describes the results as follows: After the speed-reading course, the Braille reading speed among blind Braille readers is significantly different than before taking the course, t(49) = 2.36, p =…arrow_forwardIn a case-control study researchers investigated whether there was an association between living near a high-hazard dump site versus a low-hazard dump site and risk of having a low birth weight child. The study found that in a group of women living near a high-hazard dump site while pregnant there were 181 low birth weight children and 4268 normal birth weight children. Corresponding numbers for women living near a low-hazard dump site were 126 and 4236, respectively. a. Formulate the null and alternative hypotheses. b. Estimate the odds ratio and 95% confidence interval. Interpret the result and say what the interval tells us about statistical significance. 20.arrow_forwardInspired by the example about how background music influences choice of entrée at a restaurant, a statistics student decided to investigate other ways to influence a person's behavior. Using 60 volunteers, she randomly assigned 20 volunteers to get a "red" survey, 20 volunteers to get a "blue" survey, and 20 volunteers to get a control survey. The first three questions on each survey were the same, but the fourth and fifth questions were different. For example, the fourth question on the "red" survey was "When you think of the color red, what do you think about?" On the blue survey, the question replaced red with blue. On the control survey, the last two questions were not about color. As a reward, each volunteer was allowed to choose a chocolate candy in a red wrapper or a chocolate candy in a blue wrapper. The table shows the result of the experiment. Color of candy Survey Type Red Blue Control Red 13 5 8 Blue 7 15 12 Total 20 20 20 Total 26 34 60 What are appropriate null and…arrow_forward
- Inspired by the example about how background music influences choice of entrée at a restaurant, a statistics student decided to investigate other ways to influence a person's behavior. Using 60 volunteers, she randomly assigned 20 volunteers to get a "red" survey, 20 volunteers to get a "blue" survey, and 20 volunteers to get a control survey. The first three questions on each survey were the same, but the fourth and fifth questions were different. For example, the fourth question on the "red" survey was "When you think of the color red, what do you think about?" On the blue survey, the question replaced red with blue. On the control survey, the last two questions were not about color. As a reward, each volunteer was allowed to choose a chocolate candy in a red wrapper or a chocolate candy in a blue wrapper. The table shows the result of the experiment: We want to test Ho: The distribution of candy choice is the same for subjects like these who receive the red survey, the blue survey,…arrow_forwardInspired by the example about how background music influences choice of entrée at a restaurant, a statistics student decided to investigate other ways to influence a person's behavior. Using 60 volunteers, she randomly assigned 20 volunteers to get a "red" survey, 20 volunteers to get a "blue" survey, and 20 volunteers to get a control survey. The first three questions on each survey were the same, but the fourth and fifth questions were different. For example, the fourth question on the "red" survey was "When you think of the color red, what do you think about?" On the blue survey, the question replaced red with blue. On the control survey, the last two questions were not about color. As a reward, each volunteer was allowed to choose a chocolate candy in a red wrapper or a chocolate candy in a blue wrapper. The table shows the result of the experiment. We want to test Ho: The distribution of candy choice is the same for subjects like these who receive the red survey, the blue survey,…arrow_forwardInspired by the example about how background music influences choice of entrée at a restaurant, a statistics student decided to investigate other ways to influence a person's behavior. Using 60 volunteers, she randomly assigned 20 volunteers to get a "red" survey, 20 volunteers to get a "blue" survey, and 20 volunteers to get a control survey. The first three questions on each survey were the same, but the fourth and fifth questions were different. For example, the fourth question on the "red" survey was "When you think of the color red, what do you think about?" On the blue survey, the question replaced red with blue. On the control survey, the last two questions were not about color. As a reward, each volunteer was allowed to choose a chocolate candy in a red wrapper or a chocolate candy in a blue wrapper. The table shows the result of the experiment. The statistics student will use a chi-square test for homogeneity to analyze her findings. Survey Type Which of the following are the…arrow_forward
- Glencoe Algebra 1, Student Edition, 9780079039897...AlgebraISBN:9780079039897Author:CarterPublisher:McGraw HillHolt Mcdougal Larson Pre-algebra: Student Edition...AlgebraISBN:9780547587776Author:HOLT MCDOUGALPublisher:HOLT MCDOUGALCalculus For The Life SciencesCalculusISBN:9780321964038Author:GREENWELL, Raymond N., RITCHEY, Nathan P., Lial, Margaret L.Publisher:Pearson Addison Wesley,