preview

Criminal Justice Chapter 7 Answers

Decent Essays

Chapter 7: Answer question 3 on p. 193 of the text. Please include the full text of the question in your answer. You must include a citation for each answer. No citations outside the text are required. However, you may want to cite sources to support your answer. 3. In light of Mill's basic principle, assess the legitimacy of laws (a) requiring the motorist to wear seat belts and motorcyclists to wear helmets. According to Mills freedom provides complete freedom unless it compromises the life or safety of others (Shaw,2014). If the driver drove alone and the use of seat belts or helmets would have no impact on anyone other than the individual, then the individual should be able to determine to what extent they use safety devices. Nonetheless, this assumes responsibility for self and provides that seat belts or helmets would only affect the driver. I can imagine that by not wearing a seat belt or using a helmet may have some impact on others, for instance, being thrown from a car causing someone else to wreck. Even so, if this possibility exists it is probably …show more content…

Removing the stigma from addiction would encourage more to seek treatment as well as lessening the attraction to a counter culture. No one should ever go to prison simply for possession or use of drugs. The basis of criminal justice often is swayed by the public’s approval of punishment. According to Mill (1859), real freedom is following our own path as long as you do not interfere or impede other n their pursuit of freedom (188). When an individual breaks a law that impedes upon the rights of others, that is when the criminal justice system should be involved. Relying on public entities to establish a sense of morality is ridiculous, Mill would argue that an individual has the right to pursue their own happiness even if it is not in their best interest (Shaw,2014). This is an example of people being subjected to the tyranny of the majority

Get Access