7868 unit 3 discussion 1 right one
.docx
keyboard_arrow_up
School
Capella University *
*We aren’t endorsed by this school
Course
7868
Subject
Management
Date
May 5, 2024
Type
docx
Pages
3
Uploaded by lyndie.monson on coursehero.com
Week 3 Discussion 3: Selecting a Methodological Approach
Two Methodological Approaches:
Two methodological approaches introduced this week are grounded theory and case study. Grounded theory, as described by Patton (2015), involves constructing theories grounded in empirical data, prioritizing the perspectives of participants. In contrast, a case study, outlined by Cresswell and Poth (2018), delves deeply into real-life cases through extensive data collection, resulting in detailed case descriptions and thematic analysis.
Compare and Contrast Approaches:
Grounded theory is characterized by its emphasis on developing theories rooted in empirical evidence, utilizing methods that immerse researchers in real-world contexts, and employing memoing to facilitate theory development (Patton, 2015). Conversely, a case study is known for its in-depth exploration of specific cases, often within predefined parameters, and the presentation of comprehensive insights leading to researcher-derived conclusions (Cresswell & Poth, 2018). While both approaches follow a similar research trajectory, starting with identifying
the research problem and concluding with reporting findings, they differ in their methodologies and objectives.
Subjects of Qualitative Research:
Grounded theory is particularly well-suited when researchers aim to construct theories emerging directly from empirical data, with a focus on comprehending the unfolding processes or actions over time (Patton, 2015). This methodology proves beneficial in situations where existing theoretical frameworks are limited, enabling researchers to generate fresh insights from the bottom up. Conversely, a case study is apt when researchers seek a comprehensive understanding
of specific phenomena within their real-life contexts (Cresswell & Poth, 2018). It is especially valuable for exploring intricate, multifaceted issues where a holistic perspective is essential. Both
approaches serve as valuable tools for qualitative research, each catering to distinct research questions and objectives.
References:
Cresswell, J. W., & Poth, C. N. (2018). Qualitative inquiry and research design: Choosing among
five approaches. Sage Publications.
Patton, M. Q. (2015). Qualitative research & evaluation methods: Integrating theory and practice. Sage publications.
Week 3 Discussion 1: Selecting a Methodological Approach
Tim, your thorough exploration of narrative research and phenomenology demonstrates a clear understanding of these methodological approaches and their applications in qualitative research. I appreciate how you've outlined the key characteristics of each approach, including their focus on storytelling and individual experiences. Your comparison and contrast of the two methodologies highlight important distinctions, particularly in terms of goal, data collection, and analysis methodologies. By delving into the nuances of thematic analysis and the whole-part-
whole procedure, you provide valuable insights into how these methods differ in analyzing and interpreting data.
Furthermore, your rationale for choosing narrative research and phenomenology is well-
articulated and supported by references from assigned readings. You've effectively explained how narrative research helps answer questions related to events' processes, contexts, and relationships, while phenomenology delves into the meaning of events for individuals. Your examples of research questions and interview techniques illustrate the practical application of these methodologies in studying complex phenomena such as job loss. Overall, your thoughtful analysis and clear explanations make a compelling case for the use of narrative research and phenomenology in qualitative research studies. Great job!
Cesar, your analysis of narrative research and case study methodologies is thorough and well-
articulated. You've demonstrated a clear understanding of the chosen methodological approaches
and their respective rationales for designing research studies. Your comparison and contrast of narrative research's focus on storytelling and case study's emphasis on exploring specific variables effectively highlight the unique features of each approach. Additionally, your rationale for choosing these methodologies is well-supported by references from assigned readings, including works by Creswell & Poth (2018), Priya (2021), and Scheffelaar et al. (2021).
While your analysis covers the main characteristics and applications of narrative research and case study methodologies comprehensively, one area you might consider elaborating on is the potential limitations or challenges associated with each approach. Providing insights into the potential drawbacks or constraints of using narrative research or case study methods could offer a more balanced perspective on their suitability for different research contexts.
Overall, your analysis is well-written and demonstrates a strong grasp of the concepts discussed. You've effectively synthesized information from the assigned readings to support your arguments and provided thoughtful reflections on the applications of narrative research and case study methodologies in qualitative research. Keep up the great work!
Sam, you've done an outstanding job in your analysis of phenomenological research and case study methodologies. Your explanation of each approach and their respective characteristics is clear and concise, demonstrating a strong understanding of qualitative research design. I appreciate how you've highlighted the distinct concepts and objectives of phenomenological research and case studies, as well as their differences in methodology and focus.
Your preview ends here
Eager to read complete document? Join bartleby learn and gain access to the full version
- Access to all documents
- Unlimited textbook solutions
- 24/7 expert homework help
Related Questions
Research Topic: The study of customers’ behavior towards online shopping as opposed to in-store at a Supermarket.
Research Design:
What type of research style is best for this topic: descriptive, or exploratory? Qualitative or quantitative?
What are some best research questions centered around this topic?
arrow_forward
This case study delves into the intricate process of orchestrating a charity fundraising gala
for a non-profit organization. The event aimed to raise funds for a cause dear to the
community's heart, with the goal of securing essential resources for underprivileged
children. The gala required meticulous coordination, from selecting an appropriate venue
and catering to acquiring sponsorships and inviting prominent philanthropists to attend.
Additionally, the organizers had to craft a compelling narrative that would emotionally
engage attendees and encourage generous contributions. This case study explores the
challenges faced by the organizing team and the strategies employed to overcome them,
emphasizing the importance of collaboration, community engagement, and innovative
fundraising techniques.
Question: How did the organizing team effectively mobilize community support and
leverage emotional connections to achieve their fundraising goals, and what can other non-
profit organizations…
arrow_forward
Related Course Objectives:1. Assess the role of marketing research in the design and implementation of a successful marketing programme 2. Develop research strategies that will provide sound and reliable inquiry into customer characteristics and needs3. Design research instruments and procedures that will properly collect important information4. Produce report that incisively informs management and makes recommendations to resolve issues and problemsAssignment Description and Instructions:Please study the case scenario below and propose an approach to address the needs and find solutions. Your report should:1. Include four (4) research objectives2. Describe the research design. Use three (3) qualitative methods: Focus Groups, Depth Interviews and Netnography.For each give the following details:a. Participantsi. numbers, gender, age, how selected; Justify eachb. Interviews i. how many, the setting & process, length of time; Justify eachii. questions/discussions held related to the 4…
arrow_forward
In this case study, we explore the meticulous planning and execution of a charity fundraising gala to support a local nonprofit organization. The gala aimed to raise funds for underprivileged children's education and healthcare. The organizing team faced the task of coordinating a luxurious evening event, complete with entertainment, fine dining, and silent auctions, all while staying within a limited budget. They also had to secure sponsorships, promote the event effectively, and ensure that all proceeds went directly to the cause. The study examines how the team managed to achieve their goals by leveraging volunteer support, creative cost-saving measures, and building partnerships with local businesses.
Question: How did the organizing team balance the desire for an upscale gala with the need to maximize funds for the charity, and what strategies can be adapted for similar fundraising events with limited resources?
arrow_forward
State three (2) strengths and three (2) weaknesses of focus interviews.
arrow_forward
Topic: “Challenges faced by Rural Farmers in Mt. Royal Carriacou, due to Rising Food Prices”.
Based on the topic above provide the following for the methodology report;
An introduction
A research design
Research Philosophy
Research type
Research strategy
Time horizon
arrow_forward
Q3: What is a theory? Explain three layers of the theory implementation.
details explanation
Course Title
Business Research &Report writing
arrow_forward
Briefly describe what is meant by gaining an understanding of a business problem within the framework of data analytics.
arrow_forward
Projective techniques are used less frequently than unstructured direct methods (focus groups and depth interviews). Explain which projective
technique is used commonly to test brand names and occasionally to measure attitudes about particular products, brands, packages, or
advertisements.
arrow_forward
How can staff managers ensure that their recommendations are aligned with the organization's goals and objectives?
arrow_forward
Respond to this with 200 words.
Discuss the two approaches objectively for the client to understand, talking cognizance of their benefits and drawbacks.
arrow_forward
Assume that a research study included the following question: "Why do you prefer a gasoline powered car over an electric powered car?"
Explain how you would code possible responses to this question. (Note: explore all that you think might be possible answers, not just how you would answer the question). Develop possible responses and the category groupings you would use.
arrow_forward
ou are the Head of Human Resources at a medium sized company. The Board and the CEO are concerned about falling productivity levels, the rise in absenteeism, the high turnover rate, and increasing interpersonal conflict. They are determined to turn things around. They invited a consultant to conduct a survey in the company, and she found low levels of job satisfaction and commitment among employees. They are aware that these are critical attitudes in that they influence organizational performance. However, they need clarity on a few matters, so they have asked you to prepare a note for the Board that responds to the following:
2. Explain organizational commitment and its component parts.
arrow_forward
Topic: The study of customers’ behavior towards online shopping as opposed to in-store in the Caribbean.
The research strategy is qualitative and the instrument used to collect data will be a questionnaire.
Based on the topic What questions should be asked in the questionnaire?
arrow_forward
Explanation about the concept of Action Research Model .please write more and more! thanks
human resources management
arrow_forward
There are a variety of methods of data collection in qualitative research, including observations, textual or visual analysis (e.g. from books or videos) and interviews (individual or group). However, the most common methods used, particularly in humanities and social science research, are interviews and focus group discussions.From the forerunning commentary, briefly outline the step-by-step procedures you would take for the following qualitative data collection methods when conducting your study:QUESTION 1.1Google meet interviewsQUESTION 1.2Participant observationsQUESTION 1.3Structured interviewsQUESTION 1.4Focus group discussions via Google MeetQUESTION 1.5.Direct observations
arrow_forward
How to Deal with a CaseA case study analysis requires you to investigate a business problem, examine the alternativesolutions, and propose the most effective solution or extract a key learning, using thesupporting evidence presented in the case.Before you begin writing, follow these guidelines to help you prepare and understand the casebetter:• Read the case well and take notes, or highlights to relevant facts and try to underline keyissues• Define the central issues in the case (Problem Statement)® You may refer here to the respective question it may be of help• Often it makes sense to Organize the problem statement in a hierarchical way:® Identify the single most Over-Riding Issues® Then spot any additional sub-issues, subsidiary to the main over-riding one® When dealing with them deal with the most important first• Identify Possible Root-Causes for the information provided• You need to figure out and define the Firm's strategic goals and objectives• Now you may be able to identify…
arrow_forward
Which of the following is
wrong regarding descriptive
studies? *
Offer ideas for further probing and
research.
Involve proving if a hypothesis is
wrong.
Understand the characteristics of a
group in a given situation.
Think systematically about aspects
in a given situation.
arrow_forward
From the Research Topic and questions below, kindly provide a draft response for a Proposed Methodology to include the type of research design, Ethical considerations and justification of its appropriateness to the area of study, Research instrument (e.g., questionnaire, interview schedule) Sample selection, Data collection, Proposed analysis of data and choice of statistical tests. This is for a proposed seminar presentation.
Topic: "An Analysis of the factors influencing Recruitment, Selection and Retention of Public Sector Workers in Montserrat."
Research Questions:
(1) What are the challenges that exist in the Montserratian public sector that influence the recruitment, selection and retention of workers?
(2) What steps are being currently undertaken to correct the identified challenges in the recruitment selection and retention practices in the Montserratian public service?
(3) What are the perceptions of Public Servants of the Recruitment, Selection and Retention policies and…
arrow_forward
Explain the difference between data collected by researcher, and participant produced material. Is it right to assume that the participants will always produce material better than any kind of data a researcher will collect from the field? Why?
arrow_forward
-How can the general pointers in drawing conclusions and formulating recommendations help a student as researcher?
arrow_forward
Focus Group and In-depth interview are two methods of data collection for qualitative research, discuss under which circumstance the focus group will be better than in-dept interview.
arrow_forward
Explain the advantages and disadvantages of closed-ended versus open-ended questions in a research study.
arrow_forward
The attached image is a case study.
Create an Introduction, Identify the Problem of the case, Make objectives, Make a Workable Alternative course of action (WACA), and Create a recommendation.
arrow_forward
Topic: The study of customers’ behavior towards online shopping as opposed to in-store.
The research strategy is qualitative and the instrument used to collect data will be a questionnaire.
Explain your methodological approach
Describe your methods of data collection
Describe your methods of analysis
Evaluate and justify your methodological choices
Tips for writing a strong methodology
Frequently asked questions about methodology
arrow_forward
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Management, Loose-Leaf Version
Management
ISBN:9781305969308
Author:Richard L. Daft
Publisher:South-Western College Pub
Understanding Management (MindTap Course List)
Management
ISBN:9781305502215
Author:Richard L. Daft, Dorothy Marcic
Publisher:Cengage Learning
Related Questions
- Research Topic: The study of customers’ behavior towards online shopping as opposed to in-store at a Supermarket. Research Design: What type of research style is best for this topic: descriptive, or exploratory? Qualitative or quantitative? What are some best research questions centered around this topic?arrow_forwardThis case study delves into the intricate process of orchestrating a charity fundraising gala for a non-profit organization. The event aimed to raise funds for a cause dear to the community's heart, with the goal of securing essential resources for underprivileged children. The gala required meticulous coordination, from selecting an appropriate venue and catering to acquiring sponsorships and inviting prominent philanthropists to attend. Additionally, the organizers had to craft a compelling narrative that would emotionally engage attendees and encourage generous contributions. This case study explores the challenges faced by the organizing team and the strategies employed to overcome them, emphasizing the importance of collaboration, community engagement, and innovative fundraising techniques. Question: How did the organizing team effectively mobilize community support and leverage emotional connections to achieve their fundraising goals, and what can other non- profit organizations…arrow_forwardRelated Course Objectives:1. Assess the role of marketing research in the design and implementation of a successful marketing programme 2. Develop research strategies that will provide sound and reliable inquiry into customer characteristics and needs3. Design research instruments and procedures that will properly collect important information4. Produce report that incisively informs management and makes recommendations to resolve issues and problemsAssignment Description and Instructions:Please study the case scenario below and propose an approach to address the needs and find solutions. Your report should:1. Include four (4) research objectives2. Describe the research design. Use three (3) qualitative methods: Focus Groups, Depth Interviews and Netnography.For each give the following details:a. Participantsi. numbers, gender, age, how selected; Justify eachb. Interviews i. how many, the setting & process, length of time; Justify eachii. questions/discussions held related to the 4…arrow_forward
- In this case study, we explore the meticulous planning and execution of a charity fundraising gala to support a local nonprofit organization. The gala aimed to raise funds for underprivileged children's education and healthcare. The organizing team faced the task of coordinating a luxurious evening event, complete with entertainment, fine dining, and silent auctions, all while staying within a limited budget. They also had to secure sponsorships, promote the event effectively, and ensure that all proceeds went directly to the cause. The study examines how the team managed to achieve their goals by leveraging volunteer support, creative cost-saving measures, and building partnerships with local businesses. Question: How did the organizing team balance the desire for an upscale gala with the need to maximize funds for the charity, and what strategies can be adapted for similar fundraising events with limited resources?arrow_forwardState three (2) strengths and three (2) weaknesses of focus interviews.arrow_forwardTopic: “Challenges faced by Rural Farmers in Mt. Royal Carriacou, due to Rising Food Prices”. Based on the topic above provide the following for the methodology report; An introduction A research design Research Philosophy Research type Research strategy Time horizonarrow_forward
- Q3: What is a theory? Explain three layers of the theory implementation. details explanation Course Title Business Research &Report writingarrow_forwardBriefly describe what is meant by gaining an understanding of a business problem within the framework of data analytics.arrow_forwardProjective techniques are used less frequently than unstructured direct methods (focus groups and depth interviews). Explain which projective technique is used commonly to test brand names and occasionally to measure attitudes about particular products, brands, packages, or advertisements.arrow_forward
- How can staff managers ensure that their recommendations are aligned with the organization's goals and objectives?arrow_forwardRespond to this with 200 words. Discuss the two approaches objectively for the client to understand, talking cognizance of their benefits and drawbacks.arrow_forwardAssume that a research study included the following question: "Why do you prefer a gasoline powered car over an electric powered car?" Explain how you would code possible responses to this question. (Note: explore all that you think might be possible answers, not just how you would answer the question). Develop possible responses and the category groupings you would use.arrow_forward
arrow_back_ios
SEE MORE QUESTIONS
arrow_forward_ios
Recommended textbooks for you
- Management, Loose-Leaf VersionManagementISBN:9781305969308Author:Richard L. DaftPublisher:South-Western College PubUnderstanding Management (MindTap Course List)ManagementISBN:9781305502215Author:Richard L. Daft, Dorothy MarcicPublisher:Cengage Learning
Management, Loose-Leaf Version
Management
ISBN:9781305969308
Author:Richard L. Daft
Publisher:South-Western College Pub
Understanding Management (MindTap Course List)
Management
ISBN:9781305502215
Author:Richard L. Daft, Dorothy Marcic
Publisher:Cengage Learning