Anne earned emoluments as a marketing manager with Jabem Chocolate Ltd. Jablem did not have an ESOP plan. In 2008 as a member of the management team she was offered shares in jablem which she could purchase at 50%of their marketable value. She borrowed the money from her credit union and paid for the shares in full. In 2009 jablem paid a dividend which Anne brought to account in her annual return. In 2010 and 2013 Anne received no dividends in respect of the jablem shares. In filling her returns for these years, Anne claimed deductions for the interest paid on the money she had borrowed from her credit union. Discuss whether it is likely that the interest expense will be allowable by the commissioners in the years when no dividends were earned. In your answer make reference to Thwaites v CIT{Jamaica, 1973}; woodroffe v CIT (Grenada, 1966), wharf properties limited v commissioners of inland revenue (Hong Kong 1997).
Anne earned emoluments as a marketing manager with Jabem Chocolate Ltd. Jablem did not have an ESOP plan. In 2008 as a member of the management team she was offered shares in jablem which she could purchase at 50%of their marketable value. She borrowed the money from her credit union and paid for the shares in full. In 2009 jablem paid a dividend which Anne brought to account in her annual return. In 2010 and 2013 Anne received no dividends in respect of the jablem shares. In filling her returns for these years, Anne claimed deductions for the interest paid on the money she had borrowed from her credit union. Discuss whether it is likely that the interest expense will be allowable by the commissioners in the years when no dividends were earned. In your answer make reference to Thwaites v CIT{Jamaica, 1973}; woodroffe v CIT (Grenada, 1966), wharf properties limited v commissioners of inland revenue (Hong Kong 1997).
Chapter13: Comparative Forms Of Doing Business
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 6DQ
Related questions
Question
Anne earned emoluments as a marketing manager with Jabem Chocolate Ltd. Jablem did not have an ESOP plan. In 2008 as a member of the management team she was offered shares in jablem which she could purchase at 50%of their marketable value. She borrowed the money from her credit union and paid for the shares in full. In 2009 jablem paid a dividend which Anne brought to account in her annual return. In 2010 and 2013 Anne received no dividends in respect of the jablem shares. In filling her returns for these years, Anne claimed deductions for the interest paid on the money she had borrowed from her credit union.
Discuss whether it is likely that the interest expense will be allowable by the commissioners in the years when no dividends were earned. In your answer make reference to Thwaites v CIT{Jamaica, 1973}; woodroffe
v CIT (Grenada, 1966), wharf properties limited v commissioners of inland revenue (Hong Kong 1997).
Expert Solution
This question has been solved!
Explore an expertly crafted, step-by-step solution for a thorough understanding of key concepts.
Step by step
Solved in 3 steps
Knowledge Booster
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, accounting and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.Recommended textbooks for you