preview

New Deal Dbq Essay

Decent Essays

In the years when Hoover was president, he had done nothing in order to help society with the problems they are facing. When 1932 came, the people didn’t want Hoover to be president again. When FDR gave his reasons on what he would be doing to help the people in America, the people thought that he would make a change, so they elected him as president. The problem was that Hoover had done a bad job during his term and FDR now had to find ways in order to fix what Hoover had done. But it then got worse when the Great Depression hit and FDR now had to take more responsibility and take action. During FDR’s presidency, his responses by creating programs to make the economy stable from the Great Depression were effective, but also ineffective. The …show more content…

One example was in January 1932, before FDR being elected as president, Meridel Lesueur, author of New Masses, said that women don’t have certain opportunities as men do. This implies that there was a problem that FDR will have to face when he becomes president. Also, shows how programs are only benefitting men, not women in the society. Therefore, the New Deal does not benefit everyone. After FDR was elected as president, on March 7, 1934, someone had sent a letter to Senator Robert Wagner. It was to address that the Wagner Act was not going to help economy because the anonymous person who sent the letter thought it was a socialist and communist idea. Because of this, it demonstrates that FDR didn’t make any changes to society in order to get out of the effects from the Great Depression. In addition, on November 14, 1934, William Lloyd Garrison Jr., son of the abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison, expressed his thoughts about the New Deal. He mentioned that he had mixed feelings about the New Deal and said that it was slowing down the recovery of stabilizing government. This shows that he also had doubts with the New Deal and that it will not be as effective to recover society from the Great Depression. Similarly, on 1935, Charles Evans Hughes criticizes the New Deal in a Supreme Court case. He says that the government had too much control in trying to change society. This shows that the government had too much power and that it was not effective on making the changes they needed, demonstrating that FDR’s reforms are not effective. In addition, a graph shows a period of time, starting from 1920-1945, that shows the percentage of unemployment. When looking at the graph, during the years, 1928-1936, the unemployment rate reached its highest, and it was when FDR was in presidency. This shows that FDR’s response by making programs to stabilize the economy were not as

Get Access