preview

Essay On Bad Indians And A Small Place

Decent Essays

Paragraphs are lacking flow, I simply just wrote down any ideas that came to my head.

Bad Indians and A Small Place both entail the topic of identity, the telling of their history and definition of culture. Both take on these themes differently, but especially share the same message. In A Small Place, by Jamaica Kincaid portrays the fact that tourism is an occupation of place. She accomplishes this by utilizing second person narration, expressing her disgust of tourists to the reader. On the other hand, in Bad Indians by Deborah A. Miranda, she exposes and reveals the harsh realities of colonialism through discussions of inhumane exploitation, abuse, and sexual violence. Throughout her book, she tells the history of her family and the Indigenous …show more content…

Miranda includes to use personal and sentimental works, while Kincaid uses second person narration that puts the reader in perspective of the colonizer. Identity is a prominent and significant theme in both works. More so in Bad Indians, while A Small Place entails the theme of identity as a collective. There is a distinction in terms of identity, where in Bad Indians, the reader learns about more about the author, while A Small Place is more about the history of Antigua.
Colonization has caused cultures to nearly diminish or dismantle them. Culture is a form of identity, Miranda definitely demonstrates the implications of culture as a result of colonization. On the other hand, A Small Place demonstrates that colonization still exists though, not visible to the eye, as she describes how tourism has negatively affected Antigua in her personal view.
Miranda chooses to use diaries, photographs, poems, newspapers to illustrate not only her personal life, but her family and her people. Which is a completely different element as compared to A Small place, whereas Kincaid does not illustrate these things but more so portrays history of Antigua as a

Get Access