preview

Emily Grierson Illness

Better Essays

William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” In William Faulkner’s, “A Rose for Emily,” Miss Emily Grierson lives a tragic secluded life, isolate from the world, in her house. However, upon further inspection, it appears that she has a psychological disorder which affects her relationships with her family and the community preventing her from making a true, healthy connection with the outside world. Her illness is present in all aspects of communication within the community and even within herself. It is perpetuated by the refusal of the community to talk about it and the help she receives from authorities to cloak the symptoms altogether.
Miss Emily Grierson comes from an old, traditional, aristocratic southern family. She lives her life away from …show more content…

Some of the ladies in town finally decides to send the Baptist Minister to Miss Emily to wade in this situation. According to the text, when the minister returned he never spoke of the visit, visibly shaken, and no one in the town forced the issue (Faulkner 539). The sole concern is Emily’s break with tradition to get into a relationship with a commoner. According to the text, “of course a Grierson would not think seriously of a Northerner, a day laborer” (Faulkner 538). The townspeople decide that Emily is a disgrace to traditions for stooping low to court a commoner. Jefferson townspeople, later sent for Emily’s cousins in Alabama hoping they would talk some sense in her, and that the cousin’s presence will discourage Homer. This interference, leads to the murder of Homer, as he is last seen by the people, entering the house through the back-kitchen door after the cousins left town (Faulkner 539). Later, the community observed more obvious patterns of unhealthy living in Miss Emily, her hair growing grayer, her appearance becoming more and more disheveled.
Laura Getty in “Faulkners’ ‘A Rose for Emily’ Short Story Criticism published in 2005 interjects, certain people in town knew that Homer was upstairs and argues a comparison to the recognition of Emily’s desire to hold onto Homer just as she did to her father; and the difference is, only this time they turned …show more content…

Yang compares Emily’s life to another protagonist in Faulkner’s story. According to Yang, “The truth is that she poisons Homer secretly and resolutely as she protects her dignity and reputation, and at the same time she confines her lover in her room from everlasting to everlasting, although it is only a dead body that lies in bed” (Yang, 2013). From this passage Yang implies Emily knows what she is she doing. She resulted to violence because Homer took her dignity. Pingping’s argument is that Emily is conscious is her behavior. She is aware of the reasons she bought the arsenic, used it on Homer, and then isolated herself from the town so as not to be caught in a crime of murder. There is no way to cure her, as Emily is in no way mentally

Get Access