preview

Compare And Contrast Lewis And Clark

Decent Essays

When the words “Lewis and Clark Expedition” are heard, the first thing that probably comes to mind is that they protected and were kind to Indians. That’s because the expedition was strongly outlined by the white men on the journey. Now, Indians speaking about their history and re-interpreting the evidence shows that Lewis and Clark were not the hailed heroes who respected the Native Americans on their expedition. Therefore, Lewis and Clark and their party were not respectful to the Native Americans they met because of their attempts to civilize, the name-calling, and violent acts against them. Lewis and Clark’s expedition destroyed Native American culture by trying to civilize them and take away their culture. Jefferson’s letter to Lewis …show more content…

In Lewis’ journal in Document B, R. Fields, one of the group members of Lewis and Clark’s expedition, stabbed an Indian in the heart with a knife because he took his gun. The Indian only took his gun out of curiosity, and didn’t have any intentions of hurting anyone in the group. Even though another party member asked to kill another Indian and Lewis refused, he burned the Indians’ bow and arrows and reclaimed the flag he had presented to the tribe before. “I also retook the flag but left the medal about the neck of the dead man that they might be informed who we were,” gives the chilling image of the white party triumphantly looking at the defeated and scared Indians, while leaving the medal on the dead Indian’s neck (which was used for trying to get respect and trust from them) to show the rest who is the boss around those areas. In Lewis’ speech in Document E, Lewis instructs the Otoe tribe to “do these things which your great father advises and be happy,” or else “you should bring upon your nation displeasure of your great father”. He lies to them without them knowing any better, and says that “he [the great chief] could at pleasure shut them [the mouths of all the rivers through which the traders bring goods to you] up and prevent his traders from coming among you.” If they tribe disobeys Lewis, then “the great chief” will stop providing traders with goods to trade with, and most tribes depended on those goods to

Get Access