preview

Arguments Against School Uniforms

Decent Essays

District 230 should not mandate a school uniform policy because of the following: school uniforms go against our rights, raise questions of equality, and they rely on anti-democratic principles. (MP1)To start, school uniforms go against rights in the first amendment like: freedom of religion, and freedom of speech. (EV)Robson states in his Viewpoint, ¨Symbols or words on clothes are most likely to clear the speech hurdle; they will then be evaluated against the “disruption” standard articulated by the Supreme Court in the watershed case Tinker vs. Des Moines Independent Community School District. Tinker involved students wearing black armbands to protest the war in Vietnam. Borrowing from civil rights cases, the court decided for the protesters: …show more content…

(CO)Likewise, If district d230 decided to make uniforms required, then history may repeat itself, and our speech rights may be censored as students due to the uniform dress code. (MP2)Furthermore, I disagree the d230 uniform policy because they raise questions of equality. (EV)Robson also states in his Viewpoint, ¨School dress codes also raise questions of equality. Gender-specific guidelines for hair, jewelry and cosmetics are being tested, especially by transgender students. Bans on saggy pants or Afro puffs are applied to all students but can be seen as racially biased. Outlawing sweat pants or frayed garments might well have a disproportionate effect, depending on a family’s economic status, although this argument would be more persuasive to a school board making policy than to a court applying constitutional doctrine¨ (Robson). (AN)Schools are putting gender specific guidelines on things like hair, jewelry, and cosmetics. Schools are also putting bans on things like afros, and saggy pants, which can be seen as racial discrimination. (CO)If district d230 decided to mandate uniforms, then some students feel feel

Get Access