preview

Argument On Lying

Decent Essays

“I'm not upset that you lied to me, I'm upset that from now on I can't believe you.” These were the famous words Friedrich Nietzsche spoke and almost everyone in this world can probably relate to it.Lying seems so universal, but no one can really agree if it’s warranted or not.After reviewing a few opinionated and factual articles on lying, the opinionated conclusion is lying is almost always never justified unless it is to protect someone from getting hurt. In “A Philosopher On Lying”, by Mary Alder, a philosopher named, Immanuel Kant, has his perspective on lying as, “Don’t tell someone a lie, Kant said, because then you are not treating that person with respect, as an individual.”.This statement at first glance may seem valid, but let’s take a closer look.If your mom had breast cancer and she told you about it but, said not to mention it to your dad for fear that he might get a heart attack, what would you do? Especially what shall you do if he asks you if you know anything about your mom acting weird lately? The majority of you reading this most likely have switched sides against Immanuel Kant, but, for those who think, “Well, surely he must have had made an exception about protecting someone’s life,” you are wrong. Immanuel Kant believes, “...it’s not about the size of the lie-any lie, even one to save someone’s life, is dangerous.” so if he was in that situation, he wouldn’t care if it risked his father’s life.Therefore, that is the flaw in Immanuel Kant’s argument,

Get Access