In order to find relevant information on the subject, parameters were set up to help identify the most pertinent and useful information. The articles used in this review needed to be current (published within the last 20 years). The articles moreover needed to include a suitable designed study and/or a suitable designed literature review in relevance to excessive force and the abuse of police authority. The reviewed literature included a thorough evaluation from an analysis of secondary data consisting of information gathered from criminal justice peer reviewed journal articles of when excessive force occurs the most and how force can be determined by organizational, individual and situational factors. Past law enforcement studies have …show more content…
Table 2 shows the number of results found based on the keywords as well as the studies that are used from EBSCOhost. Overall, two studies from EBSCOhost were used and two studies from Google Scholar were used as shown in Table 1 and Table 2. Harris conducted a study based on police officers observations by a neutral third party who recorded information during police citizen contacts (Harris, 2009, p.30). The study was consisted of a systematic review, which included independent/psychological variables, situational/sociological variables and organization variables. Independent variables were used to measure the characteristics of police officers. Characteristics such as the officer’s attitudes towards their job, the length of service, the race of a two-man patrol team, officer’s attitudes towards citizens, attitudes towards the use of force and an officer’s education. On behalf of Harris’ study, the length of service did not have an effect on improper force, nor did the officers attitude towards their job. However, white patrol teams were comprised of a greater percentage of improper force incidents than mixed race or black patrol partners (Harris, 2009, p.32). White officers who had a negative outlook on black individual’s had the highest percentage of using improper force compared to others
What is excessive force? According to Excessive Force Law and Legal Definitions (2016), excessive or unnecessary force by a law enforcement officer is considered a violation of a person's constitutional rights. The term “excessive force” is not exactly defined; however, the use of force greater than that which a rational and practical law enforcement officer would use under the circumstances is usually considered to be excessive. In most cases, the minimum amount force obligated to achieve a safe and effective outcome during law enforcement procedures is recommended. Let it be known that police brutality is a violation of the law. “Cruel and unusual punishments” by the police are forbidden by the Eighth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. The Fourteenth Amendment delivers further protection to individuals, prohibiting the state from robbing “any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law” (Pollock).
Chapter 4 in The Color of Justice: Race, ethnicity, and crime in America, was about the relations between society and law enforcement officers. This has been a major topic, especially in the United States for a long time. The unfortunate statistic that minorities are more likely to encounter being killed, arrested, and victimized by excessive physical force; has been a real issue even in today’s society. However, police departments are trying to combat the way police officers interact with the community; especially those of color. Although steps have been takes there are still some instances where police aggression happens. With all of the issues that arise between certain minority populated community’s police it is evident that conflict
The use of force is inevitable in police work. In many situations the lives of officers or civilians can be taken by not using force when necessary or using it improperly. Many factors come into play when an officer decides to use force. This includes is the use of force justified, has the officer been properly trained to use force, and will the department be held liable if the force is used improperly?
The use of force is without a doubt an important aspect in policing. The decision to utilize any type of force comes from a multitude of recourses; department policies, training, situational variables and ethical systems. There are three major categories in which an officers use of force is categorized under; justifiable, excessive and deadly; with a thin line between justifiable and excessive. Cases where excessive force has been used, has lead to injuries, deaths, civil damages, officers convicted and sentenced to jail and police chiefs and elected officials being removed from office (Fyfe, 1988). It is an officer`s discretion in determining when the use of force is justifiable.
The over use of force would include: unjustified shootings, severe beatings, fatal chokings, and rough treatment. Policing is a very dangerous field, the use of force is expected but the question still remains, how much force should police use? Police officers are given a continuum of force to help prevent excessive use of force, but there are still many officers that do not abide by
A study conducted by The Police Foundation surveyed 80 police officers regarding their power of authority. The survey revealed that the majority of police officers disapprove the use of excessive force. However, when situations escalate to a certain point that requires excessive force, police were asked a series of questions. They were asked questions about their attitudes regarding excessive force and their perceptions of behavior with their fellow officers. The results showed that, “Almost 25 percent felt that it is sometimes acceptable to use more force than legally allowable to control a person who physically assaults an officer (Weisburd, 24).” The survey asked police officers a question that dealt with The Code of Silence, when a police officer sees misconduct from another officer and does not report it. The response of the survery revealed that “80 percent of American police do not accept that the code of silence is an essential part of the mutual trust necessary to achieve good policing (Weisburd, 26).” When asked about the attidues of civilians of a different race, the survey results came back as, “Almost 2 in 10 police officers in the U.S. believe that whites are treated better than African Americans and other minorities (Weisburd, 30).” Is there an issue of racism or targeting certain races when it comes to police and their authortity?
Have you ever thought about what happens if a person breaks a law? What if this individual breaks a minor law and creates a larger problem? A strong topic is upon our society when it comes to law enforcement and the tough physical and verbal oppression that they have the potential to put on people when it comes to breaking the law. Police officers are supposed to be society 's saviors, guardians, and our friends. However, when things do not go quite right, and when someone breaks the law, there will always be that chance that things could escalate. These officers are supposed to deescalate situations and solve problems. That is what society relies on them at any given moment. Sometimes it takes an escalation of force to deescalate a criminal situation. This is why society sees the men and women in uniform with weapons capable of hindering life to the fullest. However, when this force is used and abused, it creates problems. The public eye becomes weary of the police in many different ways for using excessive force to deescalate a situation. Excessive force and police brutality are often caused by depression, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), anxiety, as well as other mental disorders; due to the way they are portrayed by the media, excessive force and police brutality have a direct effect on the American society as well as fellow officers in all branches of law enforcement.
Police officers are faced with a wide variety of threatening situations on the job every day, they go through an intensive training at the academy to prepare them for the safety keeping job they have. The use of force may or may not be a significant predicament but it should be viewed by the community as well as the police. Often police officers find
The media coverage of excessive force has caused outrage among citizens across the nation. The cases in Ferguson and New York have stirred up major debates about excessive police force and the meaning of justice for all within our judicial system. Protests and riots have ensued in cities across the nation and the cases are affecting us all, whether it is protesters blocking major highways during rush hour, or citizens burning down local businesses out of anger and frustration. The issue of excessive force needs to be addressed and the main question people want answered is, what causes police to use excessive force? Research has been conducted on variables such as the race of police
Most people and researchers will agree that the use of excessive force by law enforcement causes a threat to the relationship between the police and the community they serve, but there are few who might argue differently. The few individuals who argue differently claim that our awareness of police brutality is on the rise because of more media coverage and more cellphones and cameras which captures the use of force by police by posting them on the internet. Others might argue police brutality is not just a black or minority issue but an issue for all races including Caucasians. However, it is to be noted that those who are minorities mistrust law enforcement because they treat them differently. There are thousands and thousands of facts, statistics, and evidence which prove that it exists and it ruins the relationship with minority communities across Canada and the United States. How are people supposed to trust the police when they are harassed, intimidated or killed by law enforcement because of how they look? The majority of the people in low income areas are fearful of law enforcement because they do not know what will happen to them if they are stopped because they have this mindset that if the encounter goes wrong they might get killed.
Police departments have use-of-force policies that specify when force may be used and the proper level of force to be used under given circumstances. Most departments use a continuum-of-force approach that allows proportional force to the suspect’s resistance. The level of force by an officer increases in direct response to escalating resistance of the suspect. Policies such as this one have been put into place following many humiliating acts of excessive force. The policies are in place in an attempt to prevent future acts of excessive force (Pollock, 2010).
Whenever a law enforcement officer places an individual under arrest or is involved in a deadly force scenario the officer has used some degree of force. The incidents where an office has to make a split second decision and use physical force to control a situation is known as “Use of Force.” The use of force varies as situations present themselves to the officer and they must decide what level of force is necessary to control the situation. Often the use of force is subject to much debate and not a year goes by without some media coverage of some law enforcement officer accused of using excessive force. In dozens of studies of police use of force there is no single,
The use of excessive force by police officers is a topic that continues to make headlines and a study that needs to be done. Although much research has gone into this topic there still is no consensus on why the use of excessive force occurs. Some studies suggest lack of training and/or problems with organization policy/procedures. Law enforcement officers are authorized to use force when necessary, but when the level of force is excessive, however, the actions of the police come under scrutiny. The resulting effects can include; public outrage, scandal, negative reputation for not only the officer but the law enforcement community, and criminal considerations. Although there’s is no concrete definition of excessive force, police
Worden (1995) executed a police services study on 5,700 police-citizen encounters and discovered that the police use of force only amounted to 1% of all encounters. Furthermore, in 1/3 of these encounters, it was a witness who refereed the force to be unnecessary or excessive. Worden then analyzed and revised the data to include interactions only of those citizens who were suspects and even still, improper force was observed in only 1% of the encounters. Over a decade later, the findings consist with Worden remain basically unchanged.
A growing concern in America is the unnecessary use of force police officers use on the innocent or those in their custody. The role of the police officer carries both power and authority and the abuse of that power and authority raises issues society must face. This paper discusses the problem of officers who use unnecessary force, what managers and executives are doing to deal with this problem and the ethical dilemmas associated with the use of excessive or unjustified force on the police department.