preview

Adnan Syed Case Study

Decent Essays

2:15 PM, January 13,1999, students of Woodlawn High School are being released to go home. One student does not make it. Hae Min Lee disappears after school. She is found February 9,1999 in a local park, dead by manual strangulation. Days later, Adnan Syed, Hae’s former boyfriend, is arrested and soon is convicted for her murder. The court draws this conclusion from one sole person’s story; a story that constantly changes and doesn’t add up. Upon further examination, additional evidence is found that pokes holes in this person’s story and other findings produced an alibi proves Adnan’s innocence. Due to an unreliable witness, inconsistent story, and an alibi for Adnan Syed, Adnan should be proven innocent. Adnan Syed could not have committed …show more content…

Along with being popular among his peers, he was an EMT, a track athlete, a football player, and a star student. Charisma and a sterling record does not exempt someone from being guilty of a crime, however an alibi and affidavit does. Asia McClain, Adnan’s fellow schoolmate and acquaintance, they were not close but spoke every so often. McClain wrote letters to Adnan during the time of his trial. Her letters stated that, “ I’m not sure if you remember talking to me in the library on January 13, but I remember chatting with you” ( Serial Podcast ). She later writes an affidavit for Adnan. Both the affidavit and the alibi were never shown in court, thus preventing it from being considered by the jury. Since Asia McClain swears under oath that she saw him at Woodlawn High School Library at the time of Hae’s murder, then he must have been at the library; since she …show more content…

Wilds, a former friend of Adnan Syed, claims that Adnan had killed Hae. Wild’s story goes as follows: On the day of Hae’s disappearance, Adnan gives Jay his phone and his car so Jay could pick him up after he had done the “deed”. Adnan was to ask Hae if he could have a ride home, since his car was broken down. Adnan calls after the murder has been committed for Jay to come pick him up at Best Buy, which Jay does. Jay and Adnan then proceed to drive around for a while before Jay returns Adnan back to track practice. After track practice, both people bury Hae in Leakin Park. There are many holes within Jay’s story. In fact, his story changes at least 6 times. Detectives taped two of Jay’s interviews out of four, stories told in these interviews do not match up. The most prominent lie Jay has told in his interviews is where Adnan had first revealed Hae’s body in the trunk of her car. The first time he says that this happened on Edmonson Avenue and the next time he says that it was at Best Buy. One interview Jay states that Westview mall was where him and Adnan went on January, 13; the next interview Jay claims they went to Security Square Mall. Wilds has also lied about his participation in Hae’s murder, at first he says he didn’t help Adnan bury Hae and he just dropped him off somewhere, but then he says he did help him with Hae’s

Get Access