A Comparison of Stalin and Hitler as Dictators Essay

This essay will compare the three leaders who are famous for their dictatorship and totalitarianism during the 30's decade-Adolf Hitler, Benito Mussolini and Joseph Stalin. Totalitarianism is when a government gains absolute and total control over the country, including the freedom of thought and will as well as the citizen?s lifestyle, no other political parties are allowed and has the concept where the country is most important. The difference and similarity between their ideology, usage of propaganda & censorship and the method of improving the economy would be stated and explained through examples. Basically, their ultimate aim was the same, they all tried to make their country better. However, there was their own ambition wanting for

Fascism was a totalitarian political movement that developed after 1919 as a reaction against the political and social changes brought about by World War 1 and the spread of socialism and communism. It flourished between 1919 and 1945 in several countries, mainly Germany, Spain, Italy, and Japan. Fascism is a form of totalitarian dictatorship that had ideals such as extreme nationalism, economic self sufficiency and military strength. The dictators abolished all opposition against them and basically took complete control of the lives of everyone in their country.

There is no doubt that Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini shared many similar characteristics. They shared movements that were typical of National Socialism: they adopted a radical nationalism, militaristic hierarchies, violence, the cult of charismatic leadership, contempt for individual liberties and civil rights, an anti-democratic and anti-socialist orientation, and a refusal to socialize industries.

In the 1915s the Western countries had advanced technologies, a better economy and were managed successfully. However, Russia was trying something new, Communism. Lenin believed that Communism would make the country better. Shortly after his death, the man of steal, otherwise known as Stalin took control. He claimed to have the same ambitions; create a strong army, build up the industrial strength in a socialist society (Kreis, 2012). Despite their similar goals the actions they took to achieve them were completely different; Lenin is known to be on of the greatest leaders of Russia and Stalin the worst.

Hitler and Stalin will probably go down in history as two of the greatest known evil leaders of the 20th Century. You might ask what could bring two men to become the menaces they were. What kind of upbringing would cause someone to turnout the way they did?

The Impact of Stalin on Russia and the Russian People Joseph Stalin was born to a poor family in the province of Georgia in 1879. Stalin's real surname was Djugasvili; he adopted the name 'Stalin' whilst in prison as he felt the translation 'Man of Steel' would help his image. Stalin joined the Bolshevik party as a young man and soon became an active member organizing bank raids to gain money for party funds; this led to Stalin's imprisonment a number of times. Stalin first met Lenin in December 1905 in Finland and was quite surprised to see him as an ordinary man unlike the person he had imagined. In 1918 Stalin was made Commissar for Nationalities of the Bolshevik party, then in 1922 he became

Hitler as a Totalitarian Dictator Before I begin to answer the question, "to what extent was Hitler a totalitarian dictator", I must first expand on the meanings of these two widely used political terms. In the "Reader's Digest Great Encyclopaedic Dictionary", the definition of totalitarian dictator is as follows: "Totalitarian (adjective). Of, pertaining to, régime which permits no rival loyalties or parties and arrogates to itself all rights including those normally belonging to individuals. "

Not all the filmmakers have the capacity of gathering sensitive political and historical material and turn it into a pleasurable satirical parody that stirs our intellect in a totally different way. With just a couple of feature-length films, Italian-born Armando Iannucci is surely one of them, asserting his gift with comedies such as “In The Loop”, and now “The Death of Stalin”, a tongue-in-cheek caricature of the post-Stalinism struggle for power. Its conception was based on the French graphic novel of the same name.

On August 29,1939 just before world war II broke out is when German and the soviet union surprised the world by signing the German-soviet nonaggression pact, in which both sides agreed to no military action against each other. Both Hitler and Stalin were the same in what they wanted for their nations and how they were able to convince people to join their cause. Only their friendship did not last for very long. Hitler and Stalin both had the same ideas for their nations with only minor differences. Hitler wanted to turn Germany into a major superpower without any of the western nations knowing what Germany was planning.

Mussolini, Hitler, and Stalin had an immensely amount of charisma that made them the top three dictators too stand out the most. Charisma means a quality about a leader that makes people eager to follow him or her. This helped these three dictators extremely too become a leader. Mussolini was the prototype of the twentieth century charismatic dictators. His charisma attended the founding of Fascism.

There were many revolutions around the globe leading up to World War II. Though spread out were the actions, many of the ideas that were fought for were very similar. For example, two very similar revolutions were that of Italy and Russia. In both cases the revolution occurred between the socialist people, believing in social organization as a whole, and the fascist dictators in power, Stalin and Mussolini. Each side in both situations had their reasons as to why they were correct, all in accordance with Augustine's Just War Theory. Mussolini based righteousness in his cruel acts simply because he knew he could win. He knew that the Italian government was weak and there would be no challenge in his takeover. Stalin gained power through his

The first victims of Stalin’s repressions towards non-Russians, were the Soviet Koreans in 1937. The first Koreans to arrive in Russia were traders in the early 1850s but the first Koreans to settle in the far eastern territory were thirteen families in 1863. Koreans did not begin to arrive en masse to the Far East until 1866. As a result of poor conditions and crop yields in the Hamgyong region, a severe famine forced Korean families to cross the border into Russia where there were better conditions for agriculture. Entire villages moved into the Russian territory and another 500 Koreans crossed the Russian-Korean border in 1867. Most of those who arrived were peasants with barely any possessions. As the arrived, the Russian government offered them

“History was written by those who hanged the heroes” is the quote from one of the famous movie named Braveheart. During World War II, Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin were the men who stood on the opposite sides and led the greatest countries at that time. They were born to be the major figure in the world’s history. However, there are several differences between Hitler and Stalin.

After, Adolf Hitler, in 1935 had become convinced that Germany could break some of the provisions of the Treaty of Versailles without serious British and French opposition. “ Why should this war in the West be fought for the restoration of poland? The Poland of the Versailles Treaty will never rise again” Adolf Hitler had become believed, based on their responses to his early actions, that both states wanted to maintain the international status quo but without using force. Then Adolf Hitler announced to the Germans what was happening with their country Germany which they rearranged their military with new and better equipment. On march 9, 1935, Adolf Hitler announced the creation of a new air force and, one week later, the introduction of a

Two totalitarian regimes which are both political systems and influenced society significantly are Communism and Nazism. They influenced and changed people’s rights, their views on things and people in general. Communism and Nazism are the two totalitarian systems I’m going to talk about. They were spread in different areas, but both of them caused big consequences. Communism started in Russian and spread around in Eastern Europe and Nazism started in Germany and spread in that area. People have gone through many bad times when those two totalitarian systems were in power, but we can’t always say that people’s lives were better before they were in power.